The United Kingdom's Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on 19 November 2026 that the Home Office cannot keep secret the fact that it served Apple with a technical capability notice, the kind of order the company says was aimed at gaining access to encrypted iCloud data. The tribunal rejected the government's argument that confirming the notice existed would damage national security.

What did the tribunal decide?

The tribunal decided that the government can no longer hide behind its usual "neither confirm nor deny" position on whether a notice was given to Apple. In its open judgment, cited as [2026] UKIPTrib 9, a panel of Lady Carmichael (the tribunal's President), Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson said: "We reject the respondent's contention that it would be damaging to national security to confirm the fact".

The judges inferred that officials had authorised briefings to the media and that Apple had been allowed to brief United States officials. They called these significant departures from the neither-confirm-nor-deny policy. Anyone with a passing interest, they found, already knows a notice was served, so continued secrecy was "a distinction without a difference".

The tribunal gave no significant weight to the government's own assessment of the risk. It said the assessment was flawed in public-law terms because it did not account for those earlier departures.

Who brought the case?

The judgment covers joined proceedings brought by Apple Inc and by the rights groups Privacy International and Liberty together with two individuals, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner, against the Secretary of State for the Home Department. The hearing on this preliminary question took place on 17 September 2026.

Technical capability notices are issued under section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. They can require a company to maintain the ability to help authorities access data.

Why does it matter?

According to TechCrunch, Liberty said this is the first known time the government has been compelled to confirm the existence of such a secret technical order. The ruling also means that much of the main hearing can now be held in open court.

The dispute began after details of the order leaked to the media in 2025. As TechCrunch has reported, Apple responded in February 2025 by blocking UK users from enabling Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end encryption option for iCloud. US officials and lawmakers criticised the order, saying it would put Americans' privacy at risk. The UK later reportedly narrowed its demand to data belonging to British users, and Apple challenged that second order too.

What stays secret?

The judgment does not reveal what the notice actually requires. The tribunal agreed that "it would be damaging to national security if all of the material" were made public, and postponed any decision on which details can be published until the parties have exchanged evidence.

The tribunal said the two grounds about how the law should be interpreted can probably be decided in open court. Other grounds, including whether the notice is proportionate and how Apple was treated compared with other companies, are likely to need closed or private sessions.

How did Apple and the government respond?

Apple told TechCrunch it welcomed the decision to make public that the Home Office had issued a technical capability notice. It has said it has "never built a backdoor or master key" and "never will". The Home Office has not confirmed the notice and did not respond to TechCrunch's request for comment.

What's next?

A final hearing on how much of the order can be disclosed is expected next year, after evidence is exchanged.

Photo source