This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. On Friday, 20 November 2026, Eastern Railway told passengers that playing music or videos on speaker, holding loud or long phone calls, or keeping high-volume ringtones on trains and at stations could be treated as a nuisance under the Railways Act, 1989. The zone said this could mean a fine of up to ₹1,000 and/or up to six months in jail. MapMyTimes reported the warning the same day. We think the railway is right to make quiet coaches a priority. But a courtesy problem is best fixed with clear rules and fair warnings, not with the threat of prison.
What Eastern Railway has said
According to a PTI report carried by Deccan Herald, the Kolkata-headquartered zone told all four of its divisions to stop noise from mobile phones at stations and inside trains, acting on a Railway Board advisory. Its statement cited Section 145 of the Railways Act, which deals with drunkenness and nuisance. It said ticket examiners could start action against passengers who break the rule. The zone also promised regular announcements in regional languages, Hindi and English, asking passengers to use earphones and keep phones on silent, vibrate or a low ringtone volume.
Why the railway is right to act
A train compartment is a shared space, often for many hours. Night passengers want to sleep, students want to read and older travellers want some calm. One phone on speaker can spoil all of that, and asking a stranger to turn it down can start an argument. When the railway sets a clear standard, passengers no longer have to police each other. Starting with announcements in several languages is the right first step.
Where the message needs fixing
The problem is how the penalty is described. Parliament has just changed how the Railways Act deals with minor misconduct. The Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Bill, 2026, as explained in a PIB background note, was designed so that "minor everyday lapses" do not lead to criminal prosecution. For example, refusing to vacate a berth reserved for another passenger became a civil penalty of up to ₹1,000. News reports in June and July 2026 said the railway amendments took effect in July and gave Railway Protection Force staff power to impose on-the-spot penalties for several minor violations.
Against that background, warning passengers that a loud ringtone could send them to jail for six months sends a confusing message. MapMyTimes could not check the current consolidated text of Section 145 against Eastern Railway's statement, because the official India Code copy was unavailable when we tried it. The Railway Board is best placed to settle the question, and it should do so publicly. It should publish the exact current text of Section 145, say which penalties apply to phone noise, and explain who can impose them.
The case against penalties
There is a fair argument that the state should not penalise noise on trains at all. Critics could say that "loud" and "prolonged" are subjective, and that giving ticket examiners discretion over them risks arbitrary or uneven enforcement. Some passengers may not own earphones. Others may need to take urgent calls about family, work or health. On this view, courtesy should be left to announcements and social pressure, not to fines.
That argument deserves weight. Section 145 already covers nuisance, and passengers who are repeatedly disturbed need some recourse beyond arguing with a stranger. The answer to the risk of uneven enforcement is to make the process clear and fair, not to give up on enforcement.
A better way to do this
We suggest four steps. First, the railway should warn passengers before it penalises them. A request from staff to lower the volume should come before any fine, and a fine should be kept for people who refuse. Second, the Railway Board should publish one national advisory with the exact legal provision and the amount that applies. Third, the railway should count and publish how many passengers are penalised, so the public can see whether the rule is applied fairly. Fourth, it should put clear signs in coaches and send reminders with tickets.
Quiet coaches are a fair thing for passengers to ask for. The next step is to make the rule clear, proportionate and the same everywhere, so that passengers follow it because they understand it, not because they fear a jail term.
Photo source · Vikramaditya V. V., CC BY-SA 4.0




