Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on 21 November 2026 told law schools not to treat a verdict from AI-detection software as proof that a student cheated. He was giving the inaugural address at the Commonwealth Legal Education Association's (CLEA) first Annual International Conference on Legal Education in Hyderabad. LiveLaw and Bar & Bench both reported the speech.

"No student should therefore be held guilty of misconduct on the word of a machine alone," the Chief Justice said, according to both reports.

Why does the CJI distrust AI detectors?

He said the tools are unreliable and can unfairly mark honest students as cheats. To support this, he cited a 2023 study in the journal Patterns titled "GPT Detectors Are Biased Against Non-Native English Writers". In that study, seven widely used detectors labelled more than three in five essays by non-native English speakers as machine-generated.

LiveLaw reported that the researchers ran the detectors on 91 essays written for the TOEFL English test and 88 essays by students in the United States. The detectors were almost flawless on the US essays. The Chief Justice said this gap matters in the Commonwealth, where many law students do not write in their first language. Such a student, he warned, could be accused "on the strength of a number that no one can explain" and would have little means of challenging it.

Should law schools ban generative AI?

No, the Chief Justice said. He called an outright ban neither practicable nor wise. "A ban (on AI) would only drive this use out of sight, where it can be neither guided nor examined," Bar & Bench quoted him as saying.

He accepted that generative AI tools can summarise judgments, suggest arguments and produce polished answers within seconds. The question for teachers, he said, is whether the work a student submits reflects that student's own reasoning and understanding of the law. As one example of a workable approach, he pointed to Singapore's Supreme Court, which lets court users work with generative AI but holds them fully responsible for what they file.

His proposal is that law schools publish clear rules and teach responsible use. Students should know in advance which uses of AI are allowed, which must be disclosed, and which would amount to handing over the thinking they are expected to do themselves.

Changing how students are tested

"Assessment, too, must evolve, so that written work is supported by an oral explanation," the Chief Justice said. Other options he listed were asking students to defend the authorities they rely on, or to find the mistakes in an answer written by a machine. "In the end, a law school must be able to certify, with confidence, what its graduates themselves know and can do," LiveLaw quoted him as saying.

Legal aid as a condition for graduating

The Chief Justice also used the speech to suggest that every law student complete a minimum period of legal aid work before graduating. "I would further suggest that a minimum period of legal aid work be made compulsory for every student to graduate," he said, according to Bar & Bench. Students who did more than the minimum would earn extra credit, and legal aid clinics should keep running during semester breaks.

He also criticised internship certificates given to students who never attended chambers and clinical grades awarded for work that was never done. Such practices, he said, fail both the student and the clients that student will later serve.

Why it matters

The speech was addressed to the law schools that decide how students are assessed and disciplined. A public warning from the head of the Indian judiciary that these scores should not, on their own, decide a misconduct case is likely to carry weight with institutions setting their own policies. These were recommendations in a speech, not a court order or binding rule, and regulators have not yet announced any change to legal education rules in response.

The speech follows an earlier warning in the courts about unchecked AI use. MapMyTimes has argued that state lawyers need a verification rule after the Madhya Pradesh High Court rebuked fake, AI-style citations.

Photo source