Italy's data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited 805 million euros, saying the Facebook app for Android phones reached into the photo galleries of Italian users without asking for specific consent and without telling them clearly what was happening. The decision, announced in Rome on 14 November 2026, has drawn wide international coverage, and Meta says it intends to appeal.
In dollar terms, international outlets reported the penalty at roughly $880 million to $887 million. The Garante said the amount equals about 0.47 per cent of the Meta group's worldwide turnover. Al Jazeera described it as the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever imposed.
What the regulator found
The case turns on a Facebook feature that the Garante's English text calls "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook", which has been available since 2023. While a person scrolls through Facebook, the feature surfaces photos and videos from the phone's own gallery as ideas for new posts.
According to the authority, the Android app gained access to photos, videos and their associated metadata stored on users' smartphones. Its technical checks found three main problems:
- Gallery access was requested through a single permission that covered the whole app and several functions with different needs, rather than a request tied to this feature.
- That permission was preceded by a vague prompt about enabling "other features", which, the Garante said, did not let users understand that they were also switching on gallery suggestions.
- The feature was switched on by default. The regulator said a fully granted permission of this kind lets the app read the device's entire photo archive, usually on a permanent basis, without the user or the authority being able to verify which information is actually used.
The Garante estimated that about 20 million Android users in Italy were involved.
The legal basis: phones as private space
The authority did not rely on the EU's General Data Protection Regulation alone. It said Meta breached Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, the provision that brings the EU ePrivacy directive into Italian law. That rule, the Garante said, treats a smartphone as part of a person's private sphere, so any access to information stored on it needs free and informed consent, whether or not data is transmitted and whether or not anyone suffers harm.
Meta had argued that Italy was the wrong venue and that Ireland's data protection authority should handle the matter, since the company's European base is in Ireland. The Garante rejected that objection, saying the ePrivacy rules do not include the "one-stop-shop" mechanism that channels many GDPR cases to a lead regulator.
How the case unfolded
- 2023: the gallery-suggestions feature becomes available on Facebook, according to the Garante.
- July 2025: the investigation begins after a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection centre in Bolzano. The authority adds its own technical analysis.
- 2026: Meta launches a newer feature that allows gallery content to be processed in the cloud. The Garante says it will examine this separately.
- 14 November 2026: the Garante announces the 805-million-euro fine and a set of compliance orders.
Why the fine is so large
The Garante listed the factors behind the amount: the large number of people affected; the duration of the breach, which it said is still continuing for users who have not updated the app and for those who already granted the system permission; an earlier 2019 measure against the company; and what it called poor cooperation during the investigation. It counted as mitigating the changes Meta made after the complaint, but described them as late and limited to people who update the app.
What Meta must do now
Beyond the penalty, the regulator set deadlines. Within 60 days Meta must:
- ask for consent through a separate, specific request for this feature, explaining clearly what it is for, that it involves gallery access and how to switch it off;
- keep the feature off by default, including for people who have already granted the permission.
If the deadline passes without compliance, the feature may not be activated for users who have not given valid consent. Meta must also tell the Garante within 30 days what steps it has started and, within 90 days, what measures it has adopted.
Meta's response
A Meta spokesperson, quoted by the Italian news agency Adnkronos, said the company strongly disagrees with the regulator's assessment of the facts and its application of the law, and considers the fine disproportionate. Meta described the feature as a simple tool that helps people post photos and videos to Facebook, and said it works only if people grant permission on their device, which they can change at any time in their settings. The company said it intends to appeal.
What is established and what is not
Established: the amount of the fine, the feature concerned, the legal provision applied, the 60-, 30- and 90-day deadlines, and the regulator's estimate of about 20 million affected Android users all come from the Garante's own press release dated 14 November 2026. Meta's intention to appeal comes from its spokesperson's statement.
Not established: the Garante said its proceedings did not examine whether gallery content was used to train artificial intelligence, and Meta denies any such use. No finding has been made either way. The newer 2026 cloud-processing feature has not yet been assessed. The outcome of any appeal, and whether the penalty will be reduced or upheld, is unknown.
Why it matters for Indian readers
The Garante's order applies to users in Italy, and nothing in the decision changes how Facebook works for people in India. But the case touches on questions that India's own data protection law is about to make routine.
The Government of India notified the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Rules, 2025 on 14 November 2025 — exactly a year before the Italian decision — to give effect to the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, according to a Press Information Bureau backgrounder. The PIB document says the Rules provide an eighteen-month period for phased compliance, which, counted from the notification, runs to around May 2027. It says consent must be clear, informed and easy to understand, that individuals can withdraw it at any time, and that organisations must give a separate consent notice explaining the specific purpose for which personal data is collected and used.
The penalties under the Indian Act are also significant. According to the same PIB backgrounder, failure to maintain reasonable security safeguards can attract a penalty of up to Rs 250 crore; failing to notify a personal data breach, or violating obligations relating to children, can each attract up to Rs 200 crore; and other violations can attract up to Rs 50 crore.
The Italian case shows how a regulator can read consent rules strictly: one broad permission covering many functions, with a generic prompt and a default-on setting, was not enough. That makes it a useful reference point for anyone in India thinking about what clear, purpose-specific consent should look like once the DPDP Rules apply in full.
For individual users, the practical point is one Meta itself made in its defence: gallery access on Android depends on a permission granted on the device, and that permission can be reviewed and changed in the phone's settings.
What happens next
Meta's first compliance report to the Garante is due within 30 days, and the feature must be off by default for Italian users within 60 days unless the decision is suspended or overturned. The company's appeal, once filed, will decide whether the record penalty stands. Separately, the Garante has signalled a fresh look at Meta's 2026 cloud-based gallery feature, which could open a new front in the dispute.




