Scientists behind a United Nations report on overshooting the 1.5°C warming limit have hit back at attempts by some countries at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye, to keep the study out of the conference's main political decision. The dispute was reported by Climate Home News on 14 November, as negotiations on the summit's "cover decision" continued behind closed doors.

What happened in the talks

According to Climate Home News, which cited sources familiar with the discussions, the Arab Group of countries, led by Saudi Arabia, questioned the scientific rigour of the UN Environment Programme's (UNEP) Limiting Overshoot report during closed-door consultations on the cover decision this week, arguing that it had not been peer-reviewed.

Separately, the Like-Minded Developing Countries bloc, which the outlet said included India and China, asked that the cover decision avoid referring to reports produced outside the UN climate process. Observers saw this as an indirect reference to the UNEP study, the report said. Neither position has been set out publicly in an official statement, and the cover decision text remains under negotiation.

On the other side, the European Union, the United Kingdom, the Least Developed Countries and small island states want COP31 to treat the response to overshooting 1.5°C as a priority, according to the same report.

What the report says

UNEP published the report on 2 September 2026. According to a statement from the World Resources Institute issued the same day, it found that global warming is set to pass 1.5°C, likely within the next few years, but that temperatures could still be brought back down towards the Paris Agreement's long-term goals through deep emissions cuts, large-scale carbon removal and stronger adaptation.

Scientists push back

Climate Home News reported that 44 experts from around the world wrote the report, which largely pulls together existing research, and that a further 44 reviewers examined it over a year.

Debra Roberts, a member of the report's core team, told the outlet that the document "was certainly reviewed internally by the authors", that external peer reviewers were brought in, and that UNEP also reviewed it.

Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics and one of the report's reviewers, was more blunt. "Let's be straightforward here: the reports are being attacked because some people don't like the conclusions," he was quoted as saying.

Some authors also argued that so-called grey literature, or work published outside traditional journals, is not automatically of lower quality, pointing out that other UNEP reports and International Energy Agency analyses are routinely used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), according to the outlet. One UNEP author described the attempts to cast doubt on the report as "a distraction".

Manjeet Dhakal, a Nepalese adviser to the Least Developed Countries, told Climate Home News that such reports have been "very useful to inform policy-makers". Laurence Tubiana, chief executive of the European Climate Foundation, said the report "tells us a truth some would rather hide", the outlet reported.

A wider fight over science timelines

The row is linked to a long-running standoff at the IPCC. According to Climate Home News, most governments want the panel to finish its key assessment reports in time for the next Global Stocktake, due in November 2028, while Saudi Arabia, India and Russia, among others, argue that this timetable is too rushed for scientists and governments from developing countries to take part and review the work.

What comes next

Whether the overshoot report is mentioned in the final COP31 text will depend on how the cover decision negotiations play out in the summit's second week. The IPCC is due to hold an online meeting in early December 2026 in a further attempt to settle the timeline dispute, the outlet reported.

PS