ASEAN and China have failed to finish their long-running negotiations on a code of conduct for the South China Sea this year, the Philippines' top diplomat said on Sunday, 15 November, as the 49th ASEAN Summit wrapped up in Manila. The draft will now pass to Singapore, which chairs the bloc in 2027.

"There is no conclusion yet," Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro told reporters, according to Al Jazeera, which cited the Associated Press and Reuters. The Philippines, this year's ASEAN chair, had pledged to speed up the talks and seal a deal by the end of 2026. The Philippine Star reported that Manila had "missed its goal" of concluding a legally binding code before its chairmanship ends.

How far the talks got

Lazaro nevertheless presented the outcome as substantial progress. The parties "have reached provisional agreement on about 80 percent of the paragraphs of the draft COC," she said, as quoted by The Philippine Star and the state-run Philippine News Agency (PNA). "We are pleased to report the substantial completion of the negotiations on the ASEAN-China Code of Conduct," she added.

According to The Philippine Star, negotiators settled one of four major issues: how the code relates to the 2002 ASEAN-China Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea. The new code is to be consistent with, and build on, that declaration's principles.

What remains unresolved

Lazaro said several key questions are still open, including whether the code will be legally binding, Al Jazeera reported. "The ASEAN countries plus China have also different views on how things are," she said. She expressed hope the code could be concluded under Singapore's chairmanship.

The competing positions

Southeast Asian states want the code to reflect international law, which some of them accuse China of ignoring; Beijing says its conduct has been lawful and professional, Al Jazeera reported. China claims most of the South China Sea, overlapping the exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam. A 2016 international arbitration ruling found China's sweeping claims had no basis in international law — a decision Beijing rejects.

The Philippines accuses Chinese vessels of dangerous manoeuvres, water-cannon use and disruption of resupply missions inside its exclusive economic zone, while China accuses the Philippines of intruding on its territory, according to Al Jazeera. The reports reviewed carried no fresh Chinese statement on Sunday's outcome.

Reactions and next steps

In Manila, two deputy speakers of the House of Representatives praised the result on Monday. Paolo Ortega V said the talks had moved "from roughly 50 percent to nearly 80 percent provisional agreement in a single year," PNA reported. Jay Khonghun said: "The Philippines has laid the groundwork. Singapore can now build on what we have achieved."

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said on Monday that ASEAN and China should put the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea at the centre of the negotiations, according to PNA.

The talks have run for more than two decades. No new target date for concluding the code has been announced.

PS