The Telangana High Court has held that the police cannot keep a person under surveillance through a "rowdy sheet" merely because of old criminal cases, and has issued a set of guidelines on how such sheets are to be opened, reviewed and closed, legal news portal LiveLaw reported on Monday, 16 November 2026.

According to the report, a single-judge bench of Justice N. Tukaramji directed that the name of the petitioner, a city businessman, be removed from the rowdy sheet maintained against him. The court found that continuing the sheet without relevant, recent material and without a reasoned periodic review was arbitrary and disproportionate, and violated Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

The case

LiveLaw reported that the sheet was opened in 2008 on the basis of an FIR and had continued for about 18 years. The petitioner told the court he had been acquitted in several cases, that proceedings in another had been stopped, and that his only conviction was a fine in a 2010 case arising from a neighbourhood quarrel. He complained of continued surveillance, repeated summons to the police station and social stigma, and said his requests for deletion had gone unanswered. Senior counsel Bommagani Prabhakar appeared for him.

The State opposed the plea, saying he had seven criminal cases involving offences against public peace and that witnesses were afraid to complain against him, the report said. The respondents included the Chatrinaka police station.

The court noted, as per the report, that the Station House Officer had recommended continuing the sheet on the ground that the man was "active and energetic", and that the Assistant Commissioner of Police had endorsed it until 31 December 2026 without proper application of mind. It said a sheet cannot be continued on the strength of circumstances that existed only when it was first opened, and applied the test of legality, legitimate State interest and proportionality from the Supreme Court's Puttaswamy privacy ruling.

What the guidelines say

  • Before opening a sheet, the SHO must independently verify that the person falls within the relevant police Standing Order; FIRs or isolated cases alone are not enough.
  • Proposals must be reasoned, setting out case outcomes, material showing habitual conduct and why surveillance is needed. Senior officers must record specific reasons and not approve mechanically.
  • At renewal, the police must record whether the person was accused in any case in the past five years and separate the original grounds from fresh material. Acquittals, discharges, closure reports and compromises must be taken into account, and a gazetted officer must scrutinise the renewal independently.
  • Requests for deletion must be decided by a reasoned order, preferably within six weeks.
  • Commissioners and Superintendents of Police must supervise the process and discontinue sheets that no longer meet the criteria. Fresh action remains open if credible new material emerges.

What happens next

LiveLaw reported that the court asked the Director General of Police to issue circular instructions to all Commissioners and Superintendents of Police within four weeks, and that existing rowdy sheets are to be reviewed within three months of those instructions.

The court also made it clear, according to the report, that keeping a sheet does not by itself permit the police to summon a person repeatedly, restrict movement, interfere with his occupation or subject him to public humiliation; any such step needs separate legal justification. It added that the directions are meant to regulate preventive police powers, not to curtail their lawful use.

The report did not give the case title or the exact date on which the judgment was delivered.

PS · Kavali Chandrakanth KCK, CC BY-SA 4.0