The Telangana High Court has quashed the preventive detention of six men accused in the 2025 murder of Communist Party of India leader Kethavath Chandu Rathod in Hyderabad, ruling that a single crime, however brutal, does not make a person a habitual offender under the State's preventive detention law.
A division bench of Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya and Justice Renuka Yara allowed all six habeas corpus petitions and directed the Superintendent of Chanchalguda Central Prison to release the detenus immediately, LiveLaw reported on 18 November. The report described the judgment as delivered recently and did not give its exact date.
The murder and the detention orders
Rathod, a member of the CPI's State Council and a tribal leader, was killed in Malakpet, Hyderabad, on 15 July 2025 after a morning walk at a local park, according to LiveLaw and Telangana Today. The prosecution told the High Court that an eyewitness had recorded the attack on video.
The six accused were arrested and later granted conditional bail. The Hyderabad Police Commissioner then ordered their detention under the Telangana Prevention of Dangerous Activities Act, 1986, commonly known as the PD Act, labelling them "goondas", and the State Government approved the orders, LiveLaw reported. Telangana Today had reported on 1 December 2025 that the city police served PD Act orders on six suspects in the case.
Why the court set the orders aside
Under the Act, a person can be detained as a "goonda" only if he habitually commits certain offences, and only if his actions threaten public order. The bench treated both conditions as mandatory.
It found that every detention order rested on the same case, Rathod's murder. The orders referred to a "past criminal history" but did not identify any other specific offence, and there was no statement or material to show that the six men were habitual offenders, according to LiveLaw.
"A solitary offence cannot by itself satisfy the requirement of the word 'habitually'," the court said, as quoted by LiveLaw.
What each side argued
Senior Counsel V. Raghunath, for the detenus, argued that there was no material to establish habituality, which the Act requires. Government Pleader Swaroop Oorilla, for the State, argued that the gravity of the crime, the public place where it took place and its impact on public peace justified preventive detention, LiveLaw reported. The bench did not accept the State's argument.
What the ruling means
The decision ends the six men's preventive detention, but it does not affect the murder case itself. Preventive detention is an executive measure meant to stop a person from committing future acts, and it is separate from prosecution for an offence already alleged. The accused remain on trial for the murder, in which they had already been granted conditional bail.
The ruling adds to a line of cases in which courts have stressed that preventive detention, which allows a person to be held without trial, must meet the strict conditions of the law that permits it.




