The Supreme Court on Wednesday, 18 November, reserved its judgment on whether the retirement age of district judges and other judicial officers across the country should be raised from 60 to 62 years, after being told that States and Union Territories remain split on the proposal.

A bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana heard the matter in the long-running All India Judges Association v. Union of India case, first filed in 1989, LiveLaw reported. Before reserving its verdict, the court gave the States and UTs that are still opposed or undecided two more weeks to reconsider, and asked Attorney General R Venkataramani to make one final effort to bring them on board.

Where the States stand

Amicus curiae and Senior Advocate Siddharth Bhatnagar told the bench that 15 States and UTs now support the increase, 12 oppose it and four, namely Gujarat, Jharkhand, Delhi and Puducherry, have asked for more time, according to LiveLaw. Those opposed include Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Haryana, Bihar, Manipur, Meghalaya, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan, the report said.

Several Advocates General updated the court on their positions. Meghalaya said a proposal was pending before its Cabinet, Telangana said it had already issued an Ordinance raising the age to 62, Haryana said it would leave it to the court to pass an appropriate order, and Punjab said the matter was under active consideration and sought time.

What the lawyers argued

Senior Advocate Vijay Hansaria argued that States had been given enough time and urged the court to order the increase. He said that roughly 20% of judicial posts lie vacant at any given time, which in his view undercut the claim of an extra financial burden.

Senior Advocate Vikas Singh said the retirement age should be the same across all States. He opposed making a High Court suitability assessment compulsory, pointing out that States can already compulsorily retire officers found unfit, and asked that officers who retired in the meantime while eligible for elevation be protected. Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta raised the case of officers who retired between March and September, saying they were currently drawing neither salary nor pension.

What the bench said

Justice Bagchi dismissed the cost argument, remarking to the States, "You are agreeable to pay pension without taking work," as quoted by LiveLaw. He also said concerns about blocking younger aspirants were illusory given the existing vacancies.

Chief Justice Surya Kant said the judiciary loses an experienced officer when a judge retires early, that the proposal was about only two extra years of service, and that the court was not against new entrants. "Please don't compare civil services with judicial services," he said, according to LiveLaw. The Chief Justice asked the remaining States to come up with something constructive while the judgment is being written, saying the court wanted to close the proceedings on a positive note.

How the case got here

On 4 September, the same bench directed Chhattisgarh, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Sikkim, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal to amend their service rules to raise the retirement age of judicial officers from 60 to 62, News On AIR reported. Under that order, officers reaching 60 must clear a suitability and performance assessment by the High Court before continuing, and officers in those States who retired on or after 31 March 2026 could opt to return, provided they had not taken up another government post or office of profit. The move was linked to the persistent shortage of judges in the district judiciary.

The court had earlier held that the financial burden cited by some States was not a valid ground, reasoning that keeping officers in service longer would defer pension and retirement payouts, and that judicial officers cannot be equated with other government employees because they join service at a considerably older age.

What happens next

The opposing and undecided States and UTs have two weeks to revisit their stand. The bench will then deliver its judgment, which is expected to settle whether a uniform retirement age of 62 will apply to judicial officers nationwide.

PS