The Supreme Court on Monday upheld a written examination that Nagaland's excise department added to its constable recruitment after the job advertisement had already been issued, dismissing an appeal by candidates who argued the selection method could not be changed midway.
A bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar ruled in T. Akon Phom v. State of Nagaland (2026 INSC 1211), reported by The Morung Express and Deccan Herald, that the Gauhati High Court's Division Bench had rightly sustained the process for 46 posts.
How the dispute arose
According to the Morung Express report, the Department of Excise and Prohibition advertised 40 Excise Constable posts on 7 April 2025, and an addendum on 14 May added six more. The process originally had a physical test followed by a suitability test and viva voce. On 4 June 2025, a corrigendum issued by the Departmental Recruitment Board brought in a 100-mark written test based on the Class VIII syllabus, with the viva voce carrying 12 marks.
The report says 11,521 candidates applied, 5,985 took the physical test, 2,297 qualified for the written paper and 211 were called for interview.
A Single Judge of the Gauhati High Court's Kohima Bench quashed the corrigendum and the physical test on 16 October 2025, holding that a method of selection not in the original advertisement could not be introduced midway. A Division Bench reversed that on 23 June 2026 on the State's appeal, and the candidates then approached the Supreme Court.
What the Court held
Per the Morung Express, the bench found that Rule 5(i)(a) of the 1999 recruitment rules allows direct recruitment through a "competitive examination/selection", and that a written test on a prescribed syllabus falls within that. The Court also declined to rely on a 2016 memorandum cited by the appellants, noting that it had not been confirmed by the Selection Board or notified by the State.
The Court did not treat the midway change as arbitrary. As reported, it noted that the advertisement allowed the Board to issue corrigenda and addenda, that the change was publicised in local newspapers, that every candidate who cleared the physical test faced the same requirement, and that the appellants had not shown discrimination or prejudice. Deccan Herald adds that most appellants had themselves sat the written test knowing of the change.
The written test "provides a means of assessing candidates on a common basis," the Court said, according to the Morung Express, reasoning that an objective test lessens reliance on the more subjective viva voce.
The broader principle, as reported, is that recruiting authorities may design selection and shortlisting procedures where the rules do not lay down a detailed method.
Where the recruitment stands
The State told the Court that recruitment was completed by 30 June 2026. The select list of 46 candidates was notified on 29 June, and all of them accepted by 8 July, according to the Morung Express. The appellants had argued that the appeal was not infructuous because no one had yet been appointed.
Why it matters
The ruling is relevant to public-sector recruitment more widely. It signals that a change made after advertisement may survive judicial scrutiny where the rules leave the selection method open, the change is publicised and applied uniformly to all candidates. Each case, however, turns on the rules governing that particular recruitment, and the judgment's reasoning is tied to Nagaland's 1999 rules.
With the appeal dismissed, the High Court Division Bench's judgment stands and the 46 selections are no longer under challenge in the Supreme Court.




