The Supreme Court on Tuesday, 17 November, asked the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) to consider setting up shelters for stray cattle near toll plazas, and suggested that the authority pay for them from its Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) funds, according to an agency report carried by The New Indian Express and ThePrint.

A bench of Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and N V Anjaria was hearing an application in which the NHAI has sought clarification of the court's earlier directions on stray cattle and other animals on national highways.

What the NHAI told the court

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the authority, said it faced practical difficulties because it has no statutory power to acquire land for shelters. State governments, he argued, should be given the task of building them.

"We understand the direction, and it should be done. Stray cattle on the road is a real danger. But the problem is that we don't acquire any land, and have our own practical difficulties. The NHAI is just an authority which constructs roads," he submitted, according to the report.

He told the bench that carrying out the court's 19 May directions would cost the NHAI more than Rs 5,000 crore if it had to build shelters for stray cattle across the country.

What the bench said

Justice Mehta said the court had not asked the NHAI to bear the whole cost. "Lives are being lost due to cattle roaming on roads. We have not asked you to spend a specific amount. You are a corporation, so we only asked you to contribute something under the CSR corpus by constructing shelters for stray cattle found on the roads," the judge said, as quoted in the report.

The judge also remarked that some NHAI toll plazas keep operating even after the cost of building the road has been recovered. The Solicitor General replied that such a practice would be impermissible and that any instance of toll being collected after cost recovery would be wrong.

Background: the 19 May directions

The application arises from the suo motu case titled "In Re: City Hounded by Strays, Kids Pay Price". In its 19 May verdict, the report said, the court laid down a framework for stray animals on highways and public premises, linking it to public safety and the right to life under Article 21. It directed the NHAI, working with states and Union Territories, to put in place a comprehensive, time-bound mechanism for stray cattle and other animals on national highways.

In its fresh plea, the NHAI has asked the court to clarify that those directions do not place an independent obligation on it to establish, own or operate animal shelters, gaushalas, holding facilities or dedicated transport fleets.

Stray dog compliance also reviewed

The bench also looked at compliance with its directions on stray dogs. It noted that dogs wearing collars were still being seen on the premises of the Gujarat and Delhi High Courts.

Amicus curiae Gaurav Agarwal told the court that compliance reports had come in from 19 states. According to the report, he said Assam and Bihar needed to improve implementation, that Delhi's measures remained inadequate, and that Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh had filed affidavits with additional figures. The court reserved its order on compliance and asked those seeking to be added as parties to take their grievances to the respective High Courts.

What happens next

The Solicitor General sought time to discuss the NHAI's application with the amicus to arrive at a solution that is legally and practically workable. The bench asked the two to hold that discussion, directed Agarwal to file his response to the application, and listed the matter for hearing in January.

PS · Ray Swi-hymn, CC BY-SA 2.0