The Supreme Court on Monday, 16 November 2026, indicated that it may ask judicial academies in every state to go through High Court judgments and flag objectionable observations made in sexual offence cases, so that the High Courts can then remove them on their own, legal news portal LiveLaw reported.

The idea came up before a bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, which was hearing a case the court had taken up on its own motion over a Patna High Court order dated 9 July 2026.

What the Patna High Court had held

According to LiveLaw, the Patna High Court had held that an attempt to remove a woman's salwar and to molest her by pressing her chest did not amount to an "attempt to rape". The Supreme Court bench had earlier described those observations as "offensive", the report said.

The report noted that the Patna ruling came after the Supreme Court had already dealt with a similar issue in a separate suo motu case, in which it set aside an Allahabad High Court verdict containing comparable remarks and laid down guidelines for judges handling sexual offence cases.

What happened in court

At the start of Monday's hearing, the Chief Justice said he was inclined to step in and expunge the objectionable remarks in the Patna judgment, LiveLaw reported.

Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta then told the bench that the problem was not confined to one judgment. "These observations are so troubling. I was just doing the research," LiveLaw quoted her as saying. She clarified that she was not asking for the High Court decisions themselves to be set aside, only for the court to say that the view taken in them was incorrect. "That we can do," the Chief Justice replied, according to the report.

The Chief Justice asked Gupta to remind the bench that it would have to direct the judicial academies of every state to undertake a survey, LiveLaw reported. As described in the report, the plan under consideration has two steps:

  • state judicial academies would survey High Court judgments and identify the offending portions; and
  • once the survey is complete, the High Courts would be directed to act on their own to erase those observations.

The Chief Justice also drew a distinction between the consequences of setting aside decisions in civil matters and in criminal matters, and observed that the bench might find it difficult to issue such a direction if similar issues arose from Supreme Court judgments. "We may have to have another recourse. It's not that there is no remedy," LiveLaw quoted him as saying.

Gupta referred to the 1977 decision in V Tulasamma v V Sesha Reddi, in which, she said, the Supreme Court had overruled 150 High Court judgments. The Chief Justice asked her to hand over a compilation of the judgments she had found, the report said.

What happens next

No formal direction to the judicial academies has been issued so far; the bench only voiced its inclination, going by the LiveLaw report. Counsel for the accused in the Patna case, Himanshu Pathak, entered appearance and was given one week to file a reply, and the matter was adjourned. Notice was issued in a connected case in which Bihar Advocate General SD Sanjay appeared. The report did not mention the next date of hearing.

The matter is registered as SMW (Crl) No. 5/2026, titled as a suo motu case concerning the Patna High Court's order in Criminal Appeal (SJ) No. 775/2013 and ancillary issues.

PS