A retired employee's gratuity cannot be held back merely because the State has gone in appeal against his acquittal in a criminal case, the Supreme Court ruled on Monday, 16 November 2026, dismissing a set of appeals filed by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA), according to a report by legal news portal LiveLaw.

A bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar upheld orders directing the DDA to release the gratuity of its former employees with interest, on the condition that each of them gives an undertaking to return the money with interest if the criminal proceedings finally go against them. The case is titled Delhi Development Authority v Rajender Kumar Sharma, with connected matters.

The background

As set out in the LiveLaw report, the dispute goes back to 2001, when Delhi's Anti-Corruption Branch registered an FIR against officials of the DDA, the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the Slum and Jhuggi-Jhopri Department. They were accused of including fictitious slum dwellers in a relocation survey in connivance with property dealers.

In February 2017, a special judge convicted four of the accused and acquitted the DDA employees in this case along with seven others. The State of Delhi then sought leave from the Delhi High Court to appeal against the acquittal, and the High Court issued notice in August 2017.

The employees were later promoted provisionally, subject to the outcome of the State's challenge, and went on to retire. The DDA withheld their gratuity, amounting to Rs 18,52,224 and Rs 15,43,113, on the ground that the State's leave petition was still pending, the report said.

What the DDA argued

The authority relied on Rule 69(1)(c) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, arguing that it bars payment of gratuity until judicial proceedings are concluded and final orders are passed, LiveLaw reported.

The Central Administrative Tribunal had rejected that stand and ordered release of the gratuity with interest against an undertaking, following an earlier decision in Kishan Lal Taneja v Government of NCT of Delhi. The Delhi High Court dismissed the DDA's writ petitions on the same basis. Before the Supreme Court, the DDA argued that the Kishan Lal Taneja decision had been wrongly decided.

What the Supreme Court held

The bench did not accept that argument. According to LiveLaw, it noted that other similarly placed persons had already received relief on the strength of that decision, and held that it applied equally to these employees, who had been acquitted after a full trial.

The court agreed with the High Court that a pending application by the State, with no stay on the trial court's judgment, could not justify withholding the retirees' terminal dues. On the effect of the acquittal, LiveLaw quoted the judgment as saying: "An Appellate Court may or may not disturb the same, but until then, the acquittal continues to hold the field."

The bench distinguished a ruling cited by the DDA, Bikram Chand Rana v Himachal Pradesh Road Transport Corporation, on the ground that departmental proceedings in that case had concluded while the criminal trial was still pending. Here, the gratuity became payable after the trial had ended in acquittal, the report said.

Hardship to retirees

The court also took into account the hardship faced by elderly retirees. Making them wait for appellate proceedings of uncertain duration could render their pensionary benefits illusory, it said, noting that the delay was not of their making, according to LiveLaw.

The condition of an undertaking, the judgment said in words quoted by LiveLaw, "adequately safeguards the financial interests of the appellant-Authority."

The LiveLaw report did not mention the rate of interest or any deadline for the payment.

PS