Negotiations between the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and China on a long-awaited Code of Conduct for the South China Sea are 80 percent complete, Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said on Saturday, 14 November, on the eve of the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila.

Two figures in two days

Lazaro told a press briefing that progress on the code had picked up since the Philippines took over the ASEAN chair this year, The Manila Times reported. Her figure was higher than the one given a day earlier by the foreign ministry's ASEAN spokesperson, Dominic Xavier Imperial, who put completion at 70 percent at the newly opened International Media Center in Pasay City.

Imperial said the 70 percent figure described overall progress rather than a count of agreed paragraphs. He said the remaining work involved "certain elements that need to be refined" and issues that still needed clarification among all parties. Asked about timing, he said: "I am unable to definitively say when it will be concluded or will it be finalized within the year or not." He added that all parties remained committed to continuing the talks.

The sticking points

According to the state-run Philippine News Agency (PNA), four issues remain to be settled:

  • how the code relates to the non-binding Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea;
  • whether the final document will be legally binding;
  • its geographical scope; and
  • the definition of terms such as "self-restraint".

Imperial said Manila wants the code to guide the behaviour of all parties in the sea, and is pressing for the rights of third parties to be respected even if they are not part of the negotiations. No date has been set for the next negotiating round, PNA reported.

Deadline pressure

ASEAN and China have been working on the code for close to two decades, with formal consultations starting in 2013, according to The Manila Times. President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has said he is optimistic that the talks can conclude during the Philippines' 2026 chairmanship, in line with a three-year timeline set by ASEAN foreign ministers, and Lazaro has said negotiations may be completed by the end of the year. The Philippine Star, however, reported that a conclusion within the Philippine chairship looks unlikely.

Why it matters

The code is meant to set rules for managing tensions in one of the world's busiest and most disputed waterways. Manila's push for third-party rights is significant for countries outside the talks whose ships and trade pass through the region.

What happens next

The code is on the agenda for ASEAN meetings in Manila, where the summit and related meetings run from 15 to 17 November. Imperial said maritime security and cooperation would feature prominently at the ASEAN–China Summit, which marks the fifth anniversary of the two sides' Comprehensive Strategic Partnership. Chinese Premier Li Qiang is expected to attend on behalf of President Xi Jinping, and negotiating teams are expected to give updates as leaders gather.

PS