A Russian list of conditions for ending the war in Ukraine has set off a sharp reaction across Europe. According to reporting by Germany's Bild, Britain's Telegraph and The New York Times, the list asks NATO to pull its forces back to where they stood in 1997 and asks Britain and France to stop using their nuclear weapons to protect European allies. It also asks the West to stop arming Ukraine. Britain, Finland, Poland, Estonia and Ukraine have each said publicly that Europe's security is not Moscow's to negotiate.

The text itself has not been published. What is known so far comes from journalists who say they have seen the paper or been briefed on it, and their accounts differ on some important points. This article sets out what has been reported, who has said what on the record, and what is still unclear.

What happened

On Saturday, 14 November, The Telegraph reported that Russian negotiators had drawn up a document dated 10 November listing Moscow's demands for ending the war. The paper said the document was first reported by Bild, which belongs to the same Axel Springer group. It described the list as President Vladimir Putin's opening position for talks mediated by Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, President Donald Trump's peace envoys.

According to The Telegraph's account, the demands include:

  • Britain stops extending its nuclear protection to its European allies.
  • NATO withdraws forces from Eastern Europe and the Baltic states and returns to its 1997 borders.
  • Finland leaves NATO.
  • NATO commits not to send troops to Ukraine before Putin will consider a ceasefire.
  • Western weapons and military supplies to Ukraine stop, and Ukraine is kept out of NATO.
  • Russia keeps the Ukrainian territory it now occupies.

In return, The Telegraph said, Moscow could accept Ukraine joining the European Union, provided Kyiv is kept out of the bloc's common defence policy.

The Kyiv Post, in a report on 15 November, summarised The New York Times account. The Times reviewed what it described as an unsigned Russian position paper. In that version, NATO would also be barred from "any military activity" in Ukraine, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus and Central Asia. NATO nuclear-sharing arrangements that place US nuclear weapons in Europe would end, and both Britain and France would be barred from using their deterrents to protect allies.

Background and timeline

Both The Telegraph and the Kyiv Post note that the list largely repeats demands Russia made in late 2021, before its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. NATO and Washington rejected those demands at the time.

  • 10 November 2026: The date The Telegraph gives for the Russian document.
  • 12 November: According to sources cited by The New York Times, as summarised by the Kyiv Post, the demands were presented during talks at the Kremlin between Putin and the US envoys Witkoff and Kushner. The same day, European leaders met in Dublin for the European Political Community summit.
  • 14 November: The Telegraph publishes the list, crediting Bild.
  • 15 November: The Kyiv Post reports the New York Times account and collects European reactions.

The Telegraph also reported that Putin has agreed to restart face-to-face peace talks with the United States, Ukraine and European officials, on the condition that a new European "security architecture" is also discussed. According to the paper, EU leaders decided that Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the EU and NATO would be represented on the European side.

The numbers that matter

  • 1997: the year Russia reportedly wants NATO's force posture rolled back to, which would mean withdrawing from Poland and the Baltic states, according to the Kyiv Post's summary.
  • 32: the number of NATO allies The Telegraph says are likely to reject many of the conditions.
  • About 80%: the share of the Donbas regions of Donetsk and Luhansk that Russia occupies, according to The Telegraph.
  • Over 1.6 million: Russian military casualties, as claimed by Ukraine's foreign minister. Russia has not confirmed this figure, and we could not verify it independently.

Perspectives

Britain: Prime Minister Andy Burnham spoke after meeting European leaders in Dublin, where, according to the Kyiv Post, he rejected Russian demands to negotiate Europe's security arrangements. The Telegraph quoted him as saying: "Well, no, that's not up for negotiation. It's for Europe to decide its own arrangements, Europe and Europe alone." The Telegraph notes that the UK is the only European country that commits its submarine-based nuclear deterrent to NATO's wider defence.

Finland: Defence Minister Antti Häkkänen said, as quoted by The Telegraph: "Such matters are in no way a matter for negotiation. Russia knows that." Finland ended decades of military neutrality and joined NATO after Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Poland and the Baltics: According to the Kyiv Post, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said in Dublin that accepting Moscow's terms would be "a direct threat to Poland's security." Estonia's Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna wrote that "Europe's security is decided by Europeans," The Telegraph reported.

Ukraine: Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha mocked the idea of a post-war order modelled on the 1945 Yalta conference. In a Telegram post quoted by the Kyiv Post, he wrote that "to put forward ideas of that scale, you first have to win a world war." He said the most Putin could hope for is a ceasefire along the current line of contact.

The US envoys: Sources told The New York Times that Russian negotiators pointed to the Cold War and the Warsaw Pact as models, and that Witkoff and Kushner replied that circumstances had changed since 2021, the Kyiv Post reported. Separately, The Telegraph reported that the two envoys had floated a compromise: Ukraine would join NATO in exchange for ceding the rest of the eastern Donbas to Russia. President Volodymyr Zelensky said he would consider that idea if Washington formally proposed it and NATO's European members and Canada backed it, and that he would then put it to the Ukrainian public.

What it means for Indian readers

India is not named in any reported version of the document. But any settlement that redraws Europe's security map would shape the wider diplomatic setting in which New Delhi deals with Moscow, Kyiv, Washington and European capitals.

The reported Russian list would also bar NATO military activity in Central Asia and the South Caucasus, so the proposal reaches well beyond Europe.

What is established

  • Britain's prime minister said on the record that Europe's security arrangements are "not up for negotiation" and are for "Europe and Europe alone" to decide.
  • Finland's defence minister said on the record that the matters raised are "in no way a matter for negotiation."
  • Ukraine's foreign minister publicly dismissed a Yalta-style post-war settlement and said a ceasefire along the current line of contact was the most Russia could get.
  • Witkoff and Kushner are the US envoys working on the negotiations.

What is uncertain

  • The exact wording and status of the document. No text has been published. The Telegraph calls it Putin's opening position, while The New York Times, as summarised by the Kyiv Post, describes an unsigned position paper. We could not find an on-the-record Kremlin confirmation of its contents.
  • Whether Finland's exit from NATO is on the list. The Telegraph includes it. The Kyiv Post's summary of The New York Times version does not mention it.
  • How far the nuclear demand goes. The Telegraph's account focuses on Britain. The New York Times version, as reported, covers both Britain and France and also the end of US nuclear sharing in Europe.
  • When and where the paper was presented. The document is reportedly dated 10 November, and NYT sources link it to the 12 November Kremlin meeting. Neither Moscow nor Washington has publicly confirmed that sequence.
  • The Donbas-for-NATO idea. This is reported to come from the US envoys. Washington has not formally put it forward, and Zelensky's response depends on that happening.

What happens next

According to The Telegraph, the next step is a wider round of face-to-face talks that brings in European representatives alongside the United States, Ukraine and Russia. Russia has made discussion of Europe's security architecture a condition of those talks, while European capitals have publicly said that subject is closed.

The biggest open question is whether the published list is a real negotiating position or an opening bid that Moscow expects to bargain down. Until a text is released or Russian officials address the reports on the record, the most reliable guide is what each government has said publicly in its own name.

PS · Anton Zelenov, CC BY 3.0