Staying away from a legislature party meeting cannot be treated as walking out of the party itself, Eknath Shinde's lawyer told the Supreme Court on Tuesday, 17 November, as the court continued hearing the long-running Shiv Sena dispute. Summing up his case in four words, Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta said that "dissent is not defection", according to legal news website LiveLaw.

The matter is before a three-judge bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana. LiveLaw reported that the arguments were to continue on Wednesday, 18 November.

What the court is examining

The Uddhav Thackeray camp has challenged the Maharashtra Assembly Speaker's refusal to disqualify legislators of the Shinde group under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution, the anti-defection law. A separate petition by Uddhav Thackeray questions the Election Commission of India's decision that recognised the Shinde group as the official Shiv Sena and allowed it to use the "bow and arrow" election symbol, LiveLaw reported.

The disqualification petitions were filed by Sunil Prabhu of the Shiv Sena (UBT). They allege that members of the Shinde group invited disqualification by not attending a legislature party meeting held on 21 June 2022.

Shinde side: a meeting call is not a whip

Mehta argued that absence from such a meeting does not amount to voluntarily giving up membership of a political party, which is the ground for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule. "By not attending legislative party meeting, how have I given up membership of the political party?" LiveLaw quoted him as asking.

According to the report, his main submissions were:

  • The message about the meeting was sent on WhatsApp to Shinde's personal assistant at 12.31 pm, a minute after the meeting had started at 12.30 pm. It was only a call for a meeting and not a whip, and no resolution was passed.
  • The meeting had no agenda. Mehta said Prabhu had accepted in cross-examination that it was called because the Shinde group could not be reached and that it was an attempt at "reconciliation".
  • The disqualification notices were issued on the letterhead of the Shiv Sena legislature office and signed by Prabhu.
  • The pleadings of the petitioners did not make out a case for disqualification.

Attendance register called unreliable

Mehta also attacked the attendance register relied on by the Thackeray side. He said the petitioners' case was that the legislators defied a whip by staying away, yet the same register was being used to show that members had signed it.

He described the signatures as "fabricated", alleged that the signatures of two persons had been forged and inserted, and accused the petitioners of perjury, LiveLaw reported. He told the bench that the Speaker too had found the register unreliable. According to the report, Prabhu did not deny the discrepancy and had said it was "a matter of record".

What happens next

The LiveLaw report covers only the submissions made on behalf of Shinde on Tuesday; the Thackeray side's response to these points was not part of it. The bench has not given any ruling, and the hearing was listed to go on on Wednesday.

PS · Prashant Nadar, CC BY-SA 3.0