The Paris criminal court (cour criminelle de Paris) on the evening of Friday, 20 November 2026 convicted three former police officers over the beating of Black music producer Michel Zecler at the entrance of his Paris studio in November 2020, and accepted the prosecution's case that the violence was aggravated by racism. Each officer received a five-year sentence with most of it suspended, and all three were permanently barred from police work with immediate effect.
What sentences did the officers receive?
All three received five-year terms, but the time they must actually serve ranges from roughly one year to two years, according to France Info, which reported the verdict from the courtroom. Aurélien Lapersonne was given five years with three suspended, Philippe Tondeux, who led the patrol, five years with three and a half suspended, and Pierre Plantier five years with four suspended. Plantier's remaining year can be served under electronic tagging rather than in a cell, France 24 and Al Jazeera reported.
The court convicted the three of violence aggravated by racist insults and of forging a public record as persons holding public authority, France Info reported. Prosecutors had asked for four to six years in prison, so the sentences fell short of what the advocate general sought. The verdict came after a two-week trial and a deliberation that kept the parties waiting for nearly twelve hours.
What happened to Michel Zecler in 2020?
The officers stopped Zecler, now 47, outside his studio on 21 November 2020, during COVID-19 restrictions, saying he was not wearing a mandatory mask, according to France 24. They pushed him into the entrance of the building and beat him. A medical report recorded head and facial trauma, wounds to his lip and scalp and a complete rupture of a biceps tendon, leaving him unable to work for 45 days.
The officers' arrest report claimed Zecler had hit them and tried to grab a weapon. Footage from the studio's own security cameras, published by the online outlet Loopsider several days later, contradicted that account, France 24 reported.
Why did the court accept the racism finding?
The racist aggravating circumstance turned the violence into a crime rather than a lesser offence. The court said Zecler's account of being racially abused had stayed consistent, and that the falsified report damaged the officers' credibility when they denied using slurs, France Info and Al Jazeera reported. Zecler had described the insults to a police officer handcuffing him, at the police station, on the way to hospital and to his family, according to Al Jazeera.
The three men apologised to Zecler in court before the verdict; Plantier was in tears, Agence France-Presse reported, as cited by Al Jazeera.
How did Zecler's side react?
"Justice has been done," Zecler's lawyer, Serge Money, said, adding that the ruling "restored a man's dignity and allowed him to begin rebuilding himself", according to Al Jazeera. France Info reported that Money called the outcome a success even though, in his words, the sentences did not match the gravity of the acts, and spoke of a "Michel Zecler jurisprudence". Zecler was applauded as he left the courtroom. Some supporters said the officers should have been sent straight to prison.
Why the case matters
Rights groups and campaigners have pointed to the case as evidence of systemic racism in French policing, while guilty verdicts against officers in such cases remain rare, Al Jazeera noted. In 2024, three officers received suspended sentences over the 2017 stop-and-search in which a young Black man, Théo Luhaka, suffered permanent injuries.
What happens next?
Both the defence and the prosecution have ten days to appeal, France Info reported. Until then, the verdict is not final, although the ban on working as police officers took effect immediately.
Photo source · Cristian Bortes, CC BY 2.0




