This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. It reflects the editorial view of MapMyTimes on the Supreme Court of India's 18 November 2026 judgment quashing a land acquisition in Sundergarh district, Odisha, for which the court found gram sabha consent had never been obtained.

On 18 November 2026, a bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma set aside the acquisition of land in Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna villages of Sundergarh for mining by Dalmia Cements Bharat Limited, as MapMyTimes reported. The ruling, in Bibol Toppo & Ors. v. State of Odisha (2026 INSC 1244), holds that Section 41(3) of the 2013 land acquisition law, which requires the prior consent of the gram sabha before land in a Fifth Schedule area is acquired, is mandatory. We think the court got this right, and that the more useful question now is what governments and companies do next.

What the court found

According to the judgment, the company sought surface rights over about 273.57 acres in 2015, and the Odisha government's administrative approval of 23 August 2017 was itself conditional on the prior-consent rules applying. When the proposal went before the villages on 26 January 2020, the judgment records that it was rejected unanimously. The acquisition went ahead anyway.

The bench said the Orissa High Court's approach had reduced a mandatory requirement to "a paper formality", and then noted that here there was "not even paper consent": no consent was recorded on Form M, which the Odisha rules prescribe. In the court's words, the authorities "proceeded unhindered on the path of illegality". The judgment also found that the consent of at least 80% of affected families, required when land is taken for a private company, had not been obtained before the government considered the proposal.

The strongest case on the other side

The other side had real arguments, and they deserve a fair hearing. As the judgment records them, the Odisha government argued that the Social Impact Assessment found no alternative site, no displacement and no loss of homes, and that the land sought was small compared with the area's total cultivable land. It told the court that hundreds of affected people had consented and that most villagers would part with land for adequate compensation. It asked the court to read the gram sabha requirement in a way that would not "frustrate" acquisitions, and to treat minor lapses as inconsequential.

The company went further. According to the judgment, it questioned whether the gram sabha requirement was desirable at all, arguing that it could override the wishes of individual landowners who were willing to sell. That is not an idle concern: a village assembly's collective "no" can bind a family that would rather take the compensation.

The court declined to weigh these points against the statute. It said it would not question "the wisdom of the legislature" in making a provision mandatory while it remains valid. We agree with that restraint. If the balance struck in 2013 is wrong, it is for Parliament to change it openly. Executive officers should not dilute it village by village.

Why consent rules protect projects too

There is a practical case for strict compliance too. This acquisition began with a proposal in December 2015. Almost eleven years later it has been set aside, along with the notifications and the High Court judgment that upheld it. The court has said a fresh process may begin, but only in line with the law and its findings. Skipping the gram sabha did not save time. It cost a decade.

Parliament's own committee has flagged the same problem. The judgment cites the 24th report of the Lok Sabha Standing Committee on Rural Development and Panchayati Raj (2025-26), which expressed concern at "growing incidents" where gram sabha consent is obtained "on paper just as a formality". The committee recommended going further, by making such consent mandatory for all acquisitions and not just those in Scheduled Areas. That is for lawmakers to debate, but it shows the worry about paper consent is not confined to one court.

What should change now

We would urge four practical steps, none of which needs new legislation.

  • Record consent properly. States with Scheduled Areas should make sure gram sabha meetings on acquisitions are notified in advance, minuted on the prescribed form and made available to affected families.
  • Update land records first. The court criticised the State for questioning the villagers' standing after failing to update the record of rights during the acquisition.
  • Keep assessments independent. The bench held that putting a person with a financial and professional link to the project on the expert group violated the law. Appraisal panels should be visibly free of such links.
  • Engage before applying. Companies seeking land in Scheduled Areas should consult gram sabhas before a proposal is filed, not after it has been rejected.

None of this stops mining or industry; it asks only that the process the law already lays down be followed in good faith. When a village says no, the honest response is to change the proposal, improve the offer or argue for a change in the law, not to carry on as if the vote never happened. The Supreme Court has drawn that line clearly. Governments and companies should respect it.

Photo source · Bikash Lakra, CC BY-SA 3.0