This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. On 19 November 2026, Union Health Minister Jagat Prakash Nadda chaired the 32nd meeting of the Central Supervisory Board in New Delhi to review the Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994, widely known as the PC&PNDT Act. As MapMyTimes reported, the Health Ministry used the occasion to point out that the Sample Registration System (SRS) 2024 report puts India's sex ratio at birth at 918 girls for every 1,000 boys. Our view is that 918 is not a number to celebrate yet, and that the board should now commit to publishing the enforcement data that would show where the law is working and where it is not.
Why 918 is still a warning sign
The Health Ministry release says the SRS 2024 report shows improved figures in many states and Union Territories. That is welcome. But the improvement is slow. According to a summary of the SRS Statistical Report 2024 by The Policy Edge, published on 23 May 2026, the national figure for 2022-24 rose by just one point to 918. The same summary puts Chhattisgarh at the top with 978 and Uttarakhand at the bottom with 872.
For comparison, Our World in Data notes that the World Health Organization treats about 105 boys per 100 girls as the expected sex ratio at birth, with a normal range of roughly 103 to 107. Converted to India's way of counting, 105 boys per 100 girls works out to about 952 girls per 1,000 boys. By that yardstick, India remains well short of a natural balance, and the gap in states at the bottom of the table is wider still.
What the meeting did not tell us
The ministry's account lists sensible directions. Mr Nadda asked states and Union Territories to inspect registered facilities regularly and follow up promptly on violations. The board discussed digital processes, training for Appropriate Authorities, engagement with doctors and sharing of good practices. Mr Nadda said technology must not be allowed to facilitate sex selection or gender discrimination.
What the release did not include matters just as much. It gave no state-wise sex ratio figures, no count of inspections, no number of cases filed or convictions secured, and no timeline for any change to the rules. Without that information, citizens cannot tell whether a state's improvement comes from stronger enforcement, social change, or simply statistical noise in a sample survey.
The strongest case against tighter enforcement
Doctors have long argued that the Act is enforced unevenly and that the burden falls on paperwork rather than on sex selection itself. In August 2016, the radiologists' association IRIA said its members were being harassed by Appropriate Authorities for minor clerical mistakes in the mandatory Form F, and that such lapses were being treated as equal to sex determination, according to a Medical Dialogues report. The association threatened a nationwide strike over the issue at the time.
That concern deserves a fair hearing. Ultrasound is essential for safe pregnancy care, and a regime that frightens honest clinics away from imaging can hurt the very women the law aims to protect. The board's discussion of recommendations from the High-Level Committee on Non-Financial Regulatory Reforms suggests the government is also weighing how to reduce compliance burdens.
What should happen next
The answer is not to choose between doctors and daughters. It is to make enforcement smarter and more visible. We suggest three steps.
- Publish state-wise and, where the sample allows, district-wise sex ratio at birth figures alongside each board meeting, so progress and slippage are visible.
- Release yearly data on inspections, suspended registrations, cases filed and convictions, separating paperwork lapses from actual sex determination.
- Explain clearly how any regulatory easing will protect honest clinics without weakening action against those who reveal the sex of a foetus.
A law against sex selection works only if people believe it is being enforced fairly. The Central Supervisory Board has the mandate to make that case with data. A ratio of 918 is progress on paper; the next meeting should show the public what lies behind it.




