This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. It responds to the Reserve Bank of India's report Finances of Panchayati Raj Institutions, released on 19 November 2026, which found that gram panchayats get about 90% of their receipts as transfers from higher governments and raise only about 10% on their own. MapMyTimes reported the findings here.
Gram panchayats are elected governments with real duties. The RBI's numbers show how far they still are from running on their own money, and why that matters for the roads, taps and drains that rural households use every day.
What did the RBI find?
The RBI found that village councils have grown stronger financially but remain almost entirely dependent on money sent from above. The report, the second in a biennial series prepared by the RBI's Division of Local Finances, studied a balanced panel of 2.25 lakh gram panchayats over 2022-23 to 2024-25. According to the RBI press release, panchayat finances strengthened in 2022-23 and 2023-24, yet intergovernmental transfers still made up about 90% of total receipts.
The roughly 10% that panchayats raised themselves came mainly from non-tax sources such as interest receipts, Panchayati Raj programme funds and user charges, the RBI said. On spending, water supply and sanitation was the largest head at about 40% of total expenditure, shaped by Fifteenth Finance Commission mandates and national schemes. The RBI noted progress in rural connectivity, electrification, water supply, sanitation and community assets, but said gaps between States in access, quality and functionality persist.
The first edition, released in January 2024 and covering 2.58 lakh panchayats from 2020-21 to 2022-23, had put grant dependence at about 95% of revenues, according to the RBI's 2024 release. The two reports use different samples and years, so the figures cannot be read as a clean trend.
Why should dependence on transfers worry anyone?
It should worry anyone because a council that raises almost nothing has little room to choose its own priorities. When nine of every ten rupees arrive with a scheme label attached, the gram sabha's role shrinks to implementing plans drawn up elsewhere. It also weakens accountability: residents who pay little directly have less reason to ask how the money is spent, and panchayats that collect little have less reason to keep good records.
The RBI report points to a sharper problem. As some large gram panchayats are reclassified as town panchayats or small urban local bodies, their responsibilities may grow faster than their fiscal and administrative capacity, the central bank warned. A village that turns into a small town overnight needs solid waste management, drainage and street lighting on an urban scale, but it may still have a village-sized revenue base and staff.
The strongest case against pushing own revenue
There is a serious argument on the other side, and it deserves a fair hearing. Many rural households have low and uncertain incomes. Asking panchayats to collect more property tax or user charges could fall hardest on the poor, while the richest villages, with more valuable land, would gain the most. Transfers through Finance Commissions are designed precisely to even out such differences between rich and poor regions. Seen this way, a 90% transfer share is not a failure but the system working as intended, and the real priority should be making sure grants arrive on time and are spent well.
That argument is right about equity. But it does not answer the accountability gap, and it does not help the large panchayats the RBI says are outgrowing their budgets. Transfers and own revenue are not rivals; a council that raises even a modest, predictable share of its money is better placed to plan, borrow responsibly and maintain the assets that grants pay to build.
What should change?
The RBI's own recommendations offer a sensible path: transitional fiscal support for panchayats moving to urban status, investment in administrative capacity, and a calibrated push on own revenue through better collection and rationalised property taxes and licence fees. The emphasis on "calibrated" matters. States can start by collecting the taxes and fees already on their books, publishing collection data for every panchayat, and linking a small part of grants to improvements in collection, with protection for the poorest households.
Better data is a precondition. The RBI report is itself a step forward, and States should make panchayat accounts as easy to read as the central bank has made this summary. Village democracy will be judged by whether taps run and drains are cleaned, and that depends on councils that can pay for upkeep without waiting for the next instalment from the State capital.




