This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. It responds to the Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration's decision, announced in a statement on 18 November 2026, to suspend the food business licences of nine south Mumbai restaurants after inspections on 17 November found what the regulator described as serious hygiene and food safety lapses.

The list was striking because it included well-known names. Chetana in Kala Ghoda, Cafe Ideal in Colaba, Bayroute in Cuffe Parade and Miyan Kababs in Fort were among the outlets named in reports. According to Scroll's account of the FDA statement, inspectors alleged overflowing wet waste near a preparation counter, raw and cooked meat stored together without covers, food in non-food-grade containers on rusted racks, a live cockroach on a menu card, rodent activity and toilets close to a dessert preparation room. None of the restaurants had responded publicly when the orders were reported.

Is the crackdown the right response?

Yes, enforcement of this kind is the right response, and the FDA deserves credit for applying the law to famous kitchens as well as anonymous ones. Diners cannot see behind a kitchen door. They depend on a regulator to do that for them, and a suspension under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, which bars an outlet from buying, selling or distributing food while it is in force, is a serious and visible signal that the rules are not optional.

The same drive reached well beyond Mumbai. Asianet Newsable reported that three establishments in Thane lost their licences, six vendors at Pune's Manikbaug Khau Galli were told to stop trading for lacking valid licences or registrations, about 20,085 litres of edible oil was seized in Maval and more than 25,000 kg of areca nut was seized in Nagpur. Five people were arrested over banned gutkha and scented tobacco.

What is missing from the current approach?

What is missing is a public record that lets people judge whether the problem is getting better. This is not the first round of its kind. In July, the FDA suspended the licences of Shalimar, Noor Mohammadi and Rahmania in Bhendi Bazaar and Umerkhadi, and it said those restaurants had been given earlier chances to fix violations. Shalimar, according to that report, still had 25 major deficiencies at re-inspection after an improvement notice in April. Scroll has also reported an earlier round this year in which the FDA suspended the licences of eight Mumbai eateries.

Each round produces a burst of headlines, then silence. The November reports did not say how long the suspensions would last, what a restaurant must do to reopen or whether any outlet would contest the order. The findings were not tied to each named restaurant in every report, so three of the nine were named without any specific lapse being described. A diner reading the news cannot tell whether a suspended kitchen has since been cleaned up, or whether a restaurant that was never inspected is better or worse than one that was.

What would a fairer system look like?

The fairest answer is routine, published inspection results rather than episodic lists. Each order could state the specific findings, the date of inspection, the conditions for reopening and the date of re-inspection. When a suspension is lifted, that should be published too. India already has a framework to build on: the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India runs a Hygiene Rating scheme in which empanelled audit agencies score outlets, and the authority says the aim is to help consumers make informed choices. Enrolment, however, is opt-in, so the outlets most in need of scrutiny are the least likely to seek it. Linking state inspection outcomes to that rating, and making ratings easy to look up, would turn one-off raids into lasting information.

What is the strongest case against this?

The strongest objection deserves a hearing. Restaurant owners can argue that naming an outlet in a press statement causes lasting reputational harm before it has had a chance to respond, and that many of the findings, such as rusted racks or missing records, can be corrected within days. Workers lose wages while a kitchen is shut. Small vendors, like those at a Pune food street, may lack the paperwork rather than clean kitchens. A regulator with limited inspectors may also say that publishing detailed reports for every visit would slow enforcement down.

Those concerns argue for more transparency, not less. If findings are published alongside the restaurant's response and the reopening date, an outlet that fixes problems quickly gets credit in public, rather than carrying an unexplained suspension in search results for years. Clear, consistent records also protect the FDA from any perception that enforcement is selective.

What should happen next?

Mumbai's food culture is one of its great public goods, from old Colaba cafes to Fort kebab joints. Protecting it means ensuring that what reaches a customer's plate is safe, and that the public can see how that is being checked. The FDA has shown it is willing to act against big names. Its next step should be to show its work, so that the trust diners place in a licence is backed by evidence anyone can read.

Photo source