The Allahabad High Court has dismissed an application seeking to declare the 1968 compromise agreement over the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi–Shahi Idgah site in Mathura, Uttar Pradesh, "null and void", holding that such a relief cannot be decided without a full trial. Justice Avnish Saxena delivered the ruling on 20 November 2026; it was made public on 21 November.
The court made clear it was not deciding whether the 1968 compromise is valid. In its order, it said the application was dismissed "without effecting the merit of other suits, as the application is not taken up on its merit."
What was the application about?
The application was filed in Original Suit No. 7 of 2023, Shri Bhagwan Shrikrishna Lala Virajman and four others versus the Uttar Pradesh Sunni Central Waqf Board and three others. It asked the court to declare the compromise of 12 October 1968 null and void and to cancel two decrees passed by a Civil Judge in Mathura on 20 July 1973 and 7 November 1974 in Civil Suit No. 43 of 1967. It also sought possession of land at Khasra No. 255, Deeg Gate, Mathura, for the deity.
According to LiveLaw, the 1968 agreement was between the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sangh and the Trust Shahi Masjid Idgah, dividing the disputed land within the 13.37-acre complex and asking the two sides to keep away from each other's areas.
Why did the court refuse to decide it now?
The court noted that this suit is one of 18 suits concerning the same property, some of which have been consolidated. Because the same relief is the main relief in some of those suits, it "cannot be adjudicated without a trial", the court said, calling the application misconceived.
What else did the court decide?
The same order disposed of three other applications, all of which were dismissed. In one, a set of plaintiffs sought to recall an order of 26 September 2025 on who should represent the deity as "next friend" in the suit, arguing that it relied on two fabricated Supreme Court rulings cited by counsel for another plaintiff in the same suit. Justice Saxena said citing fabricated judgments "may amount to professional misconduct" but does not invalidate a decision that is otherwise based on sound legal principles, and found that the earlier order had not relied on them.
The court also rejected a plea to add the direct descendants of Thakur Keshav Dev Ji and members of the Jadaun clan as parties, saying it appeared to be aimed at delaying a suit pending since 2023 that "is still at the nascent stage". A fourth application, seeking changes to a 1 August 2024 order that had rejected the defendants' objections to the maintainability of 15 suits, was dismissed as an attempt to supplement that order rather than correct a clerical error.
Why it matters
The 1968 compromise and the decrees based on it are at the centre of the long-running dispute over the site in Mathura. By declining to rule on the compromise through an interim application, the court has left that question to be decided on evidence at trial in the suits where it is the main relief.
What happens next
The 18 suits will continue before the High Court. The challenge to the 1968 compromise remains open in the connected suits, where it will be examined at trial.




