The Kerala High Court on Monday, 16 November, questioned the State government over police restrictions on late-night DJ parties, telling it that law enforcement cannot be built on assumptions about nightlife. The remarks came from a Division Bench of Justices Devan Ramachandran and Basant Balaji while hearing the State's appeal in a case involving the Radisson Blu hotel in Kochi, according to reports by LiveLaw and Bar and Bench.

"Policing cannot be allowed on stereotypes," the Bench said, as quoted by LiveLaw. The same report quoted it as observing: "There is a fine line between policing and Police Raj."

What the case is about

The appeal, State of Kerala v. Mahadevan and Ors, challenges a single-judge ruling that set aside police notices issued to the hotel. LiveLaw reported that the notices restricted the hotel's operation beyond midnight and curtailed DJ parties after 11 pm. Bar and Bench reported that the Excise Department permits the hotel's bar to stay open until 3 am.

According to Bar and Bench, the single judge quashed the notices on 10 November, holding that the police may act against crime but cannot restrict licensed bars merely on suspicion of criminal activity. A clarification followed on 13 November, saying the ruling did not prevent the police from enforcing law and order, including action against drugs, by lawful means.

Questions from the Bench

The judges pressed the State on why DJ events were being singled out. "Police action should not be for DJ parties alone," the Bench said, according to Bar and Bench, which also quoted it as asking: "Are the police saying that there should be no nightlife?"

LiveLaw reported that the court asked whether a DJ party needs a licence at all, wondered how DJs could be called bad, and cautioned that such curbs would end up targeting a certain demographic. Bar and Bench reported that the Bench described a total ban as impractical and excessive and noted that being a DJ is a profession.

The State was represented by Additional Advocate General P.A. Mohammed Shah and Government Pleader Renoy Vincent, both outlets reported.

Firm line on drugs

The court made it clear that it was not against police action to prevent crime. "Drugs cannot be tolerated under any circumstances. There must be zero tolerance towards drugs," the Bench said, as quoted by LiveLaw. It directed that the crackdown on drugs and prohibited substances continue "with such force and vigour as is absolutely necessary", both reports said.

What happens next

The Bench asked the State to spell out what restrictions it proposes for DJ parties, which law would govern them and how parties in private spaces are to be regulated. Its earlier interim order continues, LiveLaw reported. The matter will be taken up again on 20 November.

PS · Augustus Binu, CC BY-SA 3.0