New York Governor Kathy Hochul on 20 November 2026 vetoed a bill that would have banned three food additives in the state: the colour additive FD&C Red No. 3, the flour additive potassium bromate and the preservative propylparaben, as MapMyTimes reported. One of her office's stated reasons was that the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has already banned Red No. 3 from food, effective January 2027. That has prompted a common question: if the dye is already on its way out nationally, what exactly is it, why was it banned, and what changes for shoppers?
What is Red No. 3?
Red No. 3 is a synthetic colour additive that US rules have permitted in foods, dietary supplements and ingested drugs. The FDA lists those authorisations under two federal regulations, 21 CFR 74.303 for food and 21 CFR 74.1303 for ingested drugs. In April 2025, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) grouped it with other petroleum-based synthetic dyes that it said it wanted phased out of the food supply.
Why did the FDA ban it?
The FDA revoked Red No. 3's authorisation because of a 1960 legal rule known as the Delaney Clause, not because of new human data. The clause, part of the Color Additives Amendment to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, bars the FDA from authorising any colour additive found to induce cancer in humans or animals. According to the FDA's page on the phase-out, the agency concluded that data submitted in a 2022 colour additive petition showed Red No. 3 causes cancer in male laboratory rats exposed to high levels.
The agency issued its order on 15 January 2025, and it was published in the Federal Register on 16 January 2025. It covers foods, including dietary supplements, and ingested drugs.
When does the ban take effect?
Food makers must stop using Red No. 3 by 15 January 2027, and makers of ingested drugs by 18 January 2028. The FDA has also asked companies to move faster. In a letter dated 14 July 2025, signed by FDA Commissioner Martin A. Makary and Deputy Commissioner for Human Foods Kyle A. Diamantas, the agency urged food manufacturers to reformulate "as soon as is practicably possible" and to finish before the January 2027 deadline. The letter noted that replacements may need wider use of already authorised colours or new ones, including colours derived from plants, and that every colour additive must meet a "reasonable certainty of no harm" standard.
What would New York's bill have done?
New York's Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act, Senate bill S1239F, went further than the federal ban in three ways. According to the bill page on the New York State Senate website, it would have:
- banned the manufacture, sale or distribution of food containing Red No. 3, potassium bromate or propylparaben, with the ban starting one year after the law took effect (the law itself would have taken effect 180 days after being signed);
- barred the sale in public schools of foods containing seven synthetic dyes: Red 3, Red 40, Blue 1, Blue 2, Green 3, Yellow 5 and Yellow 6;
- required companies to file reports with the state Agriculture and Markets Commissioner before using substances they had themselves declared "Generally Recognized as Safe" (GRAS), with those reports posted in a public database.
GRAS is a US route that lets a company decide on its own that an ingredient is safe without notifying the FDA. The bill, sponsored by State Senator Brian Kavanagh, passed the Assembly on 21 April 2026, was delivered to the Governor on 13 November 2026 and was vetoed on 20 November 2026.
Why did Governor Hochul veto it?
Her office argued that ingredients should be regulated at the federal level and warned of higher grocery prices and costs to taxpayers, according to MapMyTimes's report on the veto. It also pointed to the FDA's existing Red No. 3 ban and said a ban on bromated flour would force most New York pizza and bagel makers to change recipes. A spokesperson said the bill's goal was "laudable" but that enacting it would put New York businesses at a competitive disadvantage.
Supporters disagreed. Consumer Reports called the veto "deeply disappointing", and the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) criticised it. Cost estimates offered by the two sides differed widely. Assemblymember Anna Kelles, a co-sponsor, said she would reintroduce the bill. California banned the same three additives in 2023.
How does this affect you?
For shoppers in the United States, the federal deadline means Red No. 3 should disappear from foods and supplements made for the US market by 15 January 2027, and from ingested medicines by 18 January 2028. In New York, potassium bromate and propylparaben remain legal for now, and there will be no state-level GRAS disclosure system unless a new bill passes both houses again.
For readers elsewhere, including India, the FDA order is a US measure covering products regulated by the FDA; it does not by itself change food rules in other countries.
What is established and what is still debated?
- Established: the FDA's order, its legal basis in the Delaney Clause, the rat-study finding it relied on, and the 2027 and 2028 deadlines; the contents and veto of New York's bill.
- Debated: how much a state ban would cost consumers and businesses, and whether additive safety should be handled by states or only by federal regulators. The FDA's page on the phase-out discusses findings in rats; it does not present evidence of harm in people.
What happens next?
The next fixed date is 15 January 2027, when the federal food deadline for Red No. 3 arrives. In New York, any renewed attempt would have to start again in the legislature.




