With three days left on the clock, the UN climate summit in Antalya, Türkiye, has moved into its hardest phase. An 18-page draft of the summit's main political outcome, known as the "cover decision", was circulated on Monday, 16 November. By Tuesday, when ministers arrived to take over the talks, the European Union's climate envoy had said the text could make negotiations "untenable", small island states were asking for fossil fuel commitments, and a separate row over the timing of the next major UN climate science report had come into the open. Here is what is known, what is contested and where India figures.
This explainer follows our earlier report on the first draft of the Antalya text, which you can read here.
What happened
COP31 runs from 9 to 20 November and is hosted jointly by Türkiye and Australia. According to the AFP news agency, Australia, as co-host, published the 18-page draft on Monday. UN News described the document a day later as still "a mass of competing proposals", with ministers needing to settle major differences before Friday's deadline.
AFP reported that the draft carries a broad range of demands. Two have drawn the most attention: language on phasing out fossil fuels, which oil-rich countries have long resisted, and a call for wealthy nations to reach net-zero emissions by 2030.
Australia's Climate Minister Chris Bowen, who is steering the negotiations, acknowledged that the text contains elements that not all parties accept and said at least one more draft may come before the week ends, AFP reported.
Background: how the talks got here
The Earth Negotiations Bulletin (ENB), which tracks the talks session by session, recorded that the technical bodies wrapped up their work on Saturday, 14 November, and that COP31 President Murat Kurum then laid out the plan for the second week. Work is proceeding in four streams: ministerial engagement, consultations led by the Presidency, ministerial consultations on outstanding political issues, and continuing technical negotiations.
Kurum announced ministerial consultations on five subjects, each led by a pair of ministers, ENB reported:
- Mitigation: Carsten Schneider (Germany) and Bhupender Yadav (India)
- Climate finance: Monique Barbut (France) and Robert Borje (Philippines)
- Adaptation: Jiwoh Abdulai (Sierra Leone) and Miatta Fahnbulleh (UK)
- Just transition: Alicia Bárcena (Mexico) and Krzysztof Bolesta (Poland)
- The ocean: Julie Dabrusin (Canada) and Steven Victor (Palau)
The cover decision itself is being handled through Presidency consultations. The idea was contested even before a draft existed. ENB recorded that Russia, the Arab Group, the African Group, the Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDCs) and Argentina complained of a lack of clarity about the mandate and outcomes of the Presidency's consultations and opposed an outcome in a cover decision. The EU, the Umbrella Group, the Least Developed Countries, the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS), the Latin American grouping AILAC and Switzerland supported continued discussions, with some favouring an outcome that could go into a cover decision.
Carbon Brief, which is tracking the negotiating texts, had earlier described the planned cover text as an overarching political document meant to summarise negotiated outcomes as well as issues that are not on the official agenda. It said the text could acknowledge that warming is set to overshoot the 1.5°C limit and could include Türkiye's proposed target for electricity to supply 35% of global final energy by 2035.
The numbers that are verified
- 18 pages: the length of the first draft, according to both AFP and UN News.
- 20 November: the scheduled close of COP31. AFP noted that climate talks often overrun because decisions need consensus, which means a single country can block an outcome.
- 2028: the year of COP33, when global carbon-cutting efforts are due to be assessed. Dozens of European, African and Pacific states want the next big UN climate science assessment published before then, AFP reported.
- 916,000 deaths: the toll from extreme weather between 1996 and 2025 in Germanwatch's Climate Risk Index, released at the summit and cited by UN News. The index, covering 178 countries, says more than 5.5 billion people were affected, with heatwaves behind 40% of the deaths.
Who is saying what
The European Union: Climate envoy Wopke Hoekstra said the draft could make the negotiations "untenable" and needs significant change, AFP reported.
Small island states: Antigua and Barbuda's environment minister Michael Joseph said consensus on net zero "might be very, very difficult" and that he would like to see a commitment to phase out fossil fuels, according to AFP.
Brazil: Environment minister Joao Paulo Capobianco said deadlocks can be overcome by adjusting the wording, AFP reported.
The Arab Group: In the plenary recorded by ENB, the group said it would not accept any top-down global targets, or targets aimed at specific sectors or energy sources. Iraq said the negotiations should not target specific sectors or impose additional requirements.
The LMDCs: The group voiced concern about how the Presidency consultations were being handled, citing a lack of transparency and inclusivity, ENB reported. The Pacific small island states, the Umbrella Group, the EU and the Least Developed Countries took the opposite view, calling the process transparent and inclusive.
An unnamed European official: Speaking to AFP anonymously, the official said emerging countries want to impose as many obligations as possible on developed countries and called this tactical, pointing to a bloc that includes Saudi Arabia and India.
The second fight: the science report
Alongside the draft, the timing of the seventh assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has become a sticking point. The IPCC publishes these assessments every five to seven years and they inform global policy. AFP reported that the panel suspended its last meeting without resolving the impasse and that a new session is set for December.
Saudi Arabia is at the centre of the dispute over the timeline, according to AFP. AOSIS chair Ilana Seid called the delays "unjustifiable". On Tuesday, the Saudi delegation said it is "not seeking to delay climate science" and supports timelines that allow sufficient scientific review. It did not say when it wants the reports published, AFP noted.
Where India figures
India is in the middle of this phase in two ways. First, Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav is one of the two ministers co-facilitating the ministerial consultations on mitigation, the track that deals with emission cuts, as recorded by ENB. Second, the anonymous European official quoted by AFP named India, with Saudi Arabia, as part of a bloc seeking heavier obligations for developed countries. The reports reviewed do not carry an Indian response to that description, and it should be read as one unnamed official's view.
On process, ENB recorded India calling for clear communication and adherence to deadlines when new agenda items are proposed, and cautioning against copying practices from other environmental agreements without regard to their different mandates.
The reports reviewed do not set out any direct consequence of the draft for Indian households or industry. What the final text says on fossil fuels, finance and who must cut emissions how fast is the part that would matter, and that is not settled.
What is established and what is uncertain
Established
- An 18-page first draft of a cover decision was circulated on Monday, 16 November. AFP and UN News both report this.
- The talks are scheduled to close on Friday, 20 November.
- Ministerial consultations are under way on mitigation, finance, adaptation, just transition and the ocean, with the co-facilitators named in ENB's record.
- Australia's Chris Bowen has said the draft includes elements that not all parties accept.
- The IPCC's last meeting ended without agreement on the report timeline and it meets again in December, according to AFP.
Uncertain or contested
- Whether there will be a cover decision at all. Several groups opposed that route in the plenary recorded by ENB; others support it.
- Whether fossil fuel phase-out wording and the 2030 net-zero call for rich nations survive. The EU wants major changes, island states want fossil fuel commitments and the Arab Group rejects sector-specific or energy-specific targets.
- Whether ocean provisions stay in. UN News said they feature prominently in the first draft but may not survive the final round.
- Saudi Arabia's role on the IPCC timeline. Other countries describe delays as unjustifiable; the Saudi delegation says it is not trying to delay the science. Both accounts stand.
- Whether the process has been fair. The LMDCs say the consultations lacked transparency; the EU and others say they were transparent and inclusive.
- Whether the summit ends on time.
What happens next
Bowen has indicated that at least one further draft may be issued before the end of the week. Ministers have until Friday to close the gaps on fossil fuels and climate finance that UN News identified as the main divisions, though an overrun is possible. The IPCC timeline goes back to the panel's own session in December.
PS · Ahzaryamed, CC BY-SA 4.0




