Criminal courts in Delhi must deliver their orders on miscellaneous applications within 15 days of hearing arguments, the Delhi High Court has directed, after finding that a trial court had fixed a date nearly three months away to pronounce an order on a plea it had already heard three times. Legal news website LiveLaw reported the ruling by Justice Girish Kathpalia on Tuesday, 17 November.

What the High Court directed

According to the report, the court said that once arguments on any issue are over, whether the matter is final or miscellaneous, the order or judgment "shall be pronounced within a reasonable time".

  • Final judgments: the reasonable time is at most 30 to 45 days, in line with Section 258(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
  • All other orders: not more than 15 days after arguments conclude.

The direction applies to both Sessions Courts and Magistrates. Justice Kathpalia ordered that a copy of the judgment be sent to all Principal District and Sessions Judges in Delhi, so that it can be conveyed to the criminal courts under them, LiveLaw reported.

The case that led to the ruling

The order came on a petition by Karan Kapoor, who asked the High Court to ensure early disposal of his application pending before a trial court. The application had been filed under Section 175(3) of the BNSS.

As per the report, arguments on the application were heard three times, the first time on 20 May and the last on 31 October. Even so, the trial court listed the matter for orders on 28 January 2027.

The High Court noted that the delay was not due to the usual reasons such as the absence of witnesses or prosecutors, or a pending forensic report. The trial court's ordersheets spoke of the matter being kept for "clarifications", but the High Court did not find this convincing and said the expression appeared to have been used mechanically, the report said.

Justice Kathpalia directed the trial court to decide Kapoor's application within 15 days.

Why the court set a 15-day limit

The criminal procedure law does not lay down a specific time limit for orders on miscellaneous applications, the report noted. The High Court therefore took guidance from Section 258(1) of the BNSS, which provides for a judgment within 30 days of the conclusion of arguments, extendable to 45 days for reasons recorded in writing.

"After conclusion of arguments, the orders should be pronounced as soon as possible," the court said, according to LiveLaw. The judge observed that keeping matters undecided for an unreasonable period after hearing arguments erodes public confidence.

What it means for litigants

For people with cases in Delhi's criminal courts, the ruling sets an outer limit they can cite when an application has been argued but the order is kept pending: 15 days for miscellaneous orders and 30 to 45 days for final judgments.

The LiveLaw report did not mention the date on which the High Court passed the order or the case number.

PS · Chris Potter / StockMonkeys.com, CC BY 2.0