The Delhi High Court has held that the Centre did not follow the principles of natural justice when it cancelled the Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card of UK-based journalist and social activist Amrit Wilson, and has ordered the Ministry of Home Affairs to issue her a fresh show-cause notice that spells out the specific reasons. Justice Amit Mahajan passed the oral order in New Delhi on 19 November 2026; the signed judgment was uploaded on 21 November.
What did the court decide?
The court found that both the show-cause notice and the cancellation order were "bereft of any specific details of Anti-India activities" in which Wilson was said to have been involved, leaving her no opportunity to explain herself. "It is trite law that a SCN must specifically indicate the case that a noticee has to meet," the judge wrote. He added that her rights as an OCI cardholder under Section 7B of the Citizenship Act, 1955, could not be taken away without a proper opportunity to respond.
The court did not restore the OCI card. The cancellation order of 17 March 2023 will remain in force for four weeks or until the government passes a fresh order, whichever is earlier.
What must the government do now?
The authority must issue a fresh notice within one week setting out the specific reasons for cancellation. If it considers that the reasons cannot be put in a document, it must give Wilson the gist of the material with sensitive parts redacted, or allow her to inspect the material. She then has one week to reply, and the government must pass a fresh order within two weeks after that.
How did the case arise?
According to the judgment, Wilson was born in India and lived here until 1961, when she went to the United Kingdom for higher studies and later settled there, working as a journalist and social activist. She gave up her Indian passport for a British one in 2009, received a Person of Indian Origin (PIO) card on 3 October 2014 and, after PIO cards were abolished, an OCI card on 20 December 2017.
A show-cause notice dated 23 November 2022 alleged that she was "engaged in detrimental propaganda against the Indian government" and involved in "multiple anti-India activities". She denied the allegations in a reply on 4 December 2022 and asked for the material relied on. With no further communication for three months, her registration was cancelled under Section 7D(e) of the Citizenship Act on 17 March 2023.
Her counsel, Senior Advocate Trideep Pais, told the court that the government had not disclosed its reasons even in its counter-affidavit, saying they could be given only to the court in a sealed cover. The court noted that the counter-affidavit also gave no specific reasons.
Why it matters
The government had made the allegations in general terms and had not disclosed the underlying material to the petitioner. The ruling makes clear that a notice proposing to cancel an OCI card must tell the cardholder what specific conduct is alleged, and that where material is sensitive, the authority can share a redacted gist or allow inspection rather than withhold it altogether.
What happens next?
Under the court's timeline, the ministry has to issue the fresh notice within a week of 19 November, and a fresh decision on Wilson's OCI card should follow within about a month. The government has not publicly commented on the ruling.
Photo source · Global Residence Index, Unsplash




