The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentences of two men convicted in the 2002 Bilkis Bano gang rape and murder case and granted them bail while their appeals are heard. The order, passed on 28 October 2026 by Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale, was widely reported on Monday, 16 November, when legal news site Bar and Bench reported on it and published a copy of the order.

The two men are Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi, also known as Lala Doctor, and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, according to the case title and an earlier LiveLaw report on the same appeals. Their convictions have not been set aside. The court has only paused the sentence until it decides their challenge to a 2017 Bombay High Court judgment.

What happened

The three-page record of proceedings shows that the bench first granted leave, which means it agreed to hear the men's petitions as full appeals. It then recorded that both had been convicted of unlawful assembly, rioting, murder and gang rape under the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life with a fine, and that the Bombay High Court confirmed this on 4 May 2017.

After hearing both sides, the bench wrote that the appellants "have been under incarceration for a period of more than seventeen years" and that "one of the appellants has a severe handicap". It added: "Certainly, there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law."

On that basis the court said it would "suspend the sentence and grant bail to the appellants on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the concerned Trial Court". The appeal is to be listed for hearing "in its due course".

Background and timeline

  • 27 February 2002: The Sabarmati Express was burned at Godhra, and communal riots followed in Gujarat, as LiveLaw's account of the case records.
  • 3 March 2002: A mob attacked Bilkis Bano, then 21, and her relatives as they fled their village, Randhikpur. She was gang-raped and several relatives, including her three-year-old daughter, were killed, LiveLaw reported.
  • 16 December 2003: After local police filed closure reports, the Supreme Court handed the investigation to the CBI, which filed a charge sheet on 19 April 2004.
  • 2004–2008: The trial was moved out of Gujarat to Maharashtra. Eleven men were convicted and given life terms in 2008, Outlook and Al Jazeera reported.
  • 4 May 2017: The Bombay High Court upheld the convictions and sentences.
  • August 2022: The Gujarat government released all 11 men under its remission policy.
  • 8 January 2024: The Supreme Court cancelled the remission, holding that Gujarat was not the appropriate authority because the trial had been held in Maharashtra. The men were told to surrender within two weeks, according to Al Jazeera.
  • 17 March 2026: A bench of Justices Rajesh Bindal and Vijay Bishnoi issued notice to Gujarat and Maharashtra on the two men's petitions against the 2017 judgment, LiveLaw reported.
  • 28 October 2026: The present order was passed. The copy carries a court master's digital signature dated 29 October.

Verified data from the order

  • Case: Special Leave Petitions (Criminal) Nos. 5265-5266 of 2026, Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi @ Lala Doctor, etc. versus the State of Gujarat and another.
  • Bench: Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale.
  • Offences: Sections 143, 147, 302 read with 149, 376(2)(e) and 376(2)(g) of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Trial record: Sessions Case No. 634 of 2004, arising from FIR No. 59 of 2002 at Godhra Town police station, Panchmahal district.
  • Time in custody recorded by the court: more than 17 years.
  • Bail terms: left to the trial court.
  • Next date: none fixed.

What each side said

The convicts' lawyers: Senior Advocate Siddharth Luthra told the bench that his clients had spent more than 17 years in jail. The order records his submission that one of them was not named in the FIR and was "implicated after a substantial period of nearly three years after the occurrence". The bench was also told that one of the two is severely handicapped.

The prosecution side: Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre, appearing for the respondents, "vehemently opposed" these arguments, the order says. His position was that both the trial court and the High Court had already weighed the relevant material, "especially when the offence committed is so serious".

The bench: The judges did not comment on whether the convictions are sound. Their stated reasons were the length of custody, the handicap of one appellant and the existence of questions of fact and law still to be decided.

The order does not record any submission made on behalf of Bilkis Bano. The reports reviewed for this article, from Bar and Bench, Outlook, Oneindia and Daijiworld, carried no reaction from her or her family.

What it means for readers in India

For readers following one of the country's most closely watched riot cases, the order is easy to misread. Three points follow directly from its text.

  • It is not an acquittal. The 2017 High Court judgment confirming guilt remains in force unless the Supreme Court overturns it in the appeal.
  • It applies only to the two appellants. The order says nothing about the other nine men whose remission was cancelled in January 2024.
  • It is different from the 2022 remission. That was an executive decision by the Gujarat government to end the sentences early. This is a judicial order that pauses the sentence only while an appeal is pending.

None of the sources reviewed described any wider effect on other cases, and this article does not assume one.

What is established and what is uncertain

Established (from the order itself, and consistent across the reports):

  • The sentences of the two appellants are suspended and they are entitled to bail on terms the trial court sets.
  • The court recorded more than 17 years of incarceration and a severe handicap in one appellant as its reasons.
  • The Additional Solicitor General opposed the request.
  • The appeals against the 2017 judgment are pending, with no hearing date.

Uncertain or reported differently:

  • Which appellant is handicapped, and which was not named in the FIR. The order names neither. Outlook, citing the Hindustan Times, identified Joshi as the man with the handicap.
  • The bail conditions, and whether the two men have left prison. No report reviewed gave either detail.
  • When the order became public. An Outlook report citing the Hindustan Times described it soon after it was uploaded, while Bar and Bench and several other outlets reported it on 16 November.
  • Details of the 2002 attack. LiveLaw, Al Jazeera and Oneindia say Bilkis Bano was five months pregnant; Outlook says three months. Outlook and Al Jazeera put the number of relatives killed at seven; Oneindia puts it at 14.
  • Who the law officer represented. Daijiworld reported that the Gujarat government opposed bail; the order says only that the Additional Solicitor General appeared for the respondents.

What happens next

The trial court concerned must now fix the conditions on which the two men are released. The Supreme Court will then hear the appeals on their merits, where it can uphold or overturn the convictions. Because the order says only "in its due course", there is no indication of when that hearing will take place. The status of the remaining nine convicts is unchanged by this order.

PS