The Telangana High Court has ruled that protective homes set up for victims of human trafficking cannot be used to hold people accused of running or organising the trade, and has issued a set of directions to police, magistrates and the state government to keep the two groups apart. The order was reported by LiveLaw on Wednesday.
"Under no circumstances shall a Protective Home meant exclusively for victims be used as a place of penal detention," the division bench of Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda said, according to the report.
How the case reached court
The petition, M/s. Prajwala vs. The State of Telangana and others (WP No. 15506 of 2025), was filed by Prajwala, a non-governmental organisation that runs a protective home for trafficking survivors. It challenged an order of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate in Nampally directing it to admit a woman rescued in a raid on a spa.
The NGO told the court the woman was also an accused in a separate trafficking case, that admitting an alleged organiser endangered other residents, and that it complied only to avoid contempt. The woman was later released to her mother. Prajwala then sought wider safeguards, arguing that treating such homes as a "default custodial institution" was dangerous.
What the court directed
- Separate facilities: the State and the Director General of Police should set up separate corrective institutions for perpetrators and organisers.
- Case-by-case assessment: at the time of rescue, police must look for signs of threats, deception, debt bondage or restricted movement. A past criminal case alone does not rule out someone being a victim, but each suspect's role must be investigated separately.
- Standard operating procedure: the DGP, through the Women Safety Wing, is to put into operation the consolidated SOP dated 26 February 2026.
- Magistrates: inquiries under Section 17 of the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act must not be mechanical; police must place verified antecedents, vulnerability indicators and details of shelter suitability before an order is passed.
- Protection for NGOs: police must consult a home on space and safety before seeking a placement, and NGOs are not to be treated as all-purpose custodial facilities.
- Before and after rescues: raids should be planned with trained women officers, interpreters and child-protection staff where needed, identities kept confidential, and residents monitored afterwards for threats, recruitment attempts or renewed exploitation.
- Records and advisories: police should keep a district-wise list of recognised protective homes with their capacity and contact officers, and issue non-discriminatory advisories asking landlords to exercise due diligence.
- Children: rescued children must be dealt with under child-protection laws and produced before the competent authority.
Why the bench stressed safeguards
The court said a person cannot be branded a trafficker on the strength of an FIR or a previous accusation alone, LiveLaw reported. At the same time, it said the label of "rescued person" "would not dispense with the need for a careful risk assessment", and that "the procedural safeguards under Sections 16 and 17 must be applied in substance and not as a mere formality."
What happens next
The directions place the main follow-up with the state government, the DGP's office and magistrates who decide where rescued people are placed. The report did not mention a deadline for compliance or a further hearing date.
PS · Chanduclicks, CC BY-SA 4.0




