The Tamil Nadu government has asked the Supreme Court to reject a petition seeking to place the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy temple and the Thirupparankundram hill near Madurai under the control of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), according to a counter affidavit reported by PTI and the legal news portal LawBeat on 13 and 14 November 2026.
The affidavit was filed on behalf of the state's Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department through its Commissioner, T G Vinay, in response to a writ petition by the Hindu Dharma Parishad. LawBeat reported that the document was verified at Chennai on 12 November. The matter is before a bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi, and reports said it is listed for hearing on 17 November.
What the petition seeks
As described in the reports, the Hindu Dharma Parishad has asked the court for three reliefs: that the ASI take over and control the entire temple and hill; that a lamp be kept burning round the clock on a stone pillar on the hill that the petitioner calls the "Deepathoon"; and that the whole hill be lit with lamps during the Karthigai Deepam festival. The Supreme Court had issued notice on the petition earlier this year.
The state's main arguments
According to PTI, the HR&CE Department told the court that ownership of the hill was settled by a 1923 civil court decree that the Privy Council restored in 1931. The affidavit said, as quoted by the agency, that "a title so settled cannot be disturbed."
On the ASI question, the department argued that the administration of the temple is entrusted to it by statute. LawBeat reported that the state described the takeover demand as "wholly untenable" and said ASI protection under early twentieth-century notifications covers only specific features such as the rock-cut cave and inscriptions, not the whole hill or a functioning temple. The affidavit, as reported, said the ASI's role "does not extend to the taking over or the administration of a living temple."
On the lamp, the state said the Karthigai Deepam has traditionally been lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple, which PTI reported the affidavit described as a practice of more than 150 years followed in line with the Agamas and the opinion of the temple's Sthanikars. LawBeat quoted the affidavit as saying there had "never existed any established practice, custom or even a prior claim" of lighting the lamp at the summit, and that the term "Deepathoon" was "a recent invention" in the litigation.
Law and order and maintainability
The department also raised public order concerns. PTI reported that the affidavit said lighting lamps at several places on the hill, especially near the dargah, could disturb existing arrangements and create law and order problems at a site it described as having a history of communal tension.
On procedure, the state argued that a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution is not maintainable because no violation of a fundamental right has been shown. According to LawBeat, it also cited a 1996 Madras High Court order regulating where and by whom the lamp may be lit, earlier dismissals of similar pleas in 2014 and 2017, and the fact that a related dispute over the lamp's location is already pending before the Supreme Court. The affidavit sought that the petition be "dismissed in limine with costs," the portal reported.
Why it matters
The Thirupparankundram hill has been the subject of repeated litigation over the Karthigai Deepam. Earlier this year, the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court upheld an order allowing a lamp to be lit on the hilltop, and the state has separately challenged that order in the Supreme Court. The state's response sets out its position on who controls the temple and the hill as the top court takes up the Parishad's plea.
What happens next
The Supreme Court is expected to hear the matter on 17 November. The court has not ruled on any of the contentions in the affidavit, and the petitioner's response to the state's arguments has not yet been reported.




