The Supreme Court on Monday, 16 November 2026, dismissed the appeals against a National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) order that had set aside the approval given to Twin Star Technologies' resolution plan for 13 Videocon group companies and returned the matter to the lenders. The ruling leaves the January 2022 NCLAT decision standing, nearly five years after it was delivered.

A Bench of Justices P S Narasimha and Alok Aradhe pronounced the verdict, according to reports by Bar and Bench, The Economic Times and Mint. Bar and Bench quoted the court as saying: "We have upheld the power of the NCLAT to send the approved resolution plan to the CoC. And for the reasons assigned by us, we have dismissed all the appeals." The legal news site added that the court has also laid down guidelines on how the appellate tribunal should use that power, and that the detailed judgment was awaited at the time of its report.

What the plan offered

Twin Star Technologies, a Vedanta group company, had proposed to take over 13 Videocon group companies through a consolidated insolvency process. Bar and Bench and Mint put the offer at about ₹2,962 crore against admitted claims of roughly ₹65,000 crore; Mint said this worked out to a haircut of 95.85% for creditors. The Economic Times report gave the bid value as ₹2,692 crore, a figure that differs from the other two reports.

The Mumbai bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) approved the plan on 8 June 2021 after lenders holding 95.09% of the voting share in the Committee of Creditors (CoC) backed it, Bar and Bench reported.

Why the NCLAT set it aside

Three lenders that voted against the plan, Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and the Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI), went to the NCLAT. According to Mint, they argued that they were being offered less than they would be entitled to if Videocon were liquidated, and objected to being paid partly through non-convertible debentures rather than cash.

On 5 January 2022 the NCLAT set aside the NCLT's approval and sent the plan back to the CoC. Bar and Bench reported that the appellate tribunal found the plan did not meet the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code's safeguards for payments to dissenting financial creditors, and held that such creditors could not be forced to accept securities in place of money. The tribunal also said the NCLT's direction to pay in cash amounted to changing the plan, something only the CoC could consider.

Two further points weighed with the tribunal, according to the same report: lenders holding 94.98% of the voting share who had first supported the plan later asked for it to be reconsidered because of the steep haircut, and the Competition Commission of India's approval had not been obtained before the CoC cleared the plan.

Dhoot's plea on overseas oil assets rejected

The Economic Times reported that the Supreme Court also rejected a plea by former Videocon chairman and managing director Venugopal N Dhoot, who wanted the foreign oil and gas assets of group entities such as Videocon Oil Ventures and Videocon Hydrocarbon Holdings to be treated as assets of Videocon Industries Ltd for its insolvency process. The NCLAT had earlier turned down that request, holding that it would interfere with the commercial wisdom of the creditors, the newspaper said.

Mint separately reported that the NCLT's Mumbai bench declared Dhoot bankrupt on 5 November over dues of ₹12,668 crore claimed by State Bank of India.

What happens next

With the appeals dismissed, lenders can resume the stalled resolution process and go ahead with fresh bidding, Mint reported. The paper cited a Videocon Industries filing of 19 January 2022 which said the CoC had decided, after the NCLAT order, to invite fresh expressions of interest for a consolidated resolution plan.

The full text of the Supreme Court judgment, including the guidelines on when the NCLAT may send an approved plan back to creditors, will show how far the ruling affects other insolvency cases. Mint said its queries to the three dissenting lenders and to the resolution professional had not been answered by the time of its report.

PS · Legaleagle86 at English Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0