The Supreme Court on Tuesday, 17 November, told Shiv Sena (UBT) Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut that an apology in a contempt matter "must come from the heart and not the mind", and directed both him and journalist Nikhil Wagle to file fresh affidavits and be present in court in person on 8 December, according to reports by LiveLaw and LawBeat.

A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi was hearing a criminal contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over social media posts concerning Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and the judiciary. Raut attended the hearing in person, while Wagle joined by video link, LawBeat reported.

What the bench said

LiveLaw quoted Justice Aravind Kumar as telling Raut: "You have expressed apology. But in a matter of this magnitude, apology must come from the heart and not the mind." The judge added that as a seasoned politician and parliamentarian, Raut ought to know the restraint expected of him. LawBeat reported the bench as saying he "should know what restraint in language means".

On the press, Justice Kumar recalled that his own father's passport recorded his profession as journalist, described the media as the "fourth estate" and noted that the court had often come to the rescue of journalists, according to LiveLaw.

What was ordered

  • Raut is to file an affidavit responding to social media posts he is said to have made after tendering his apology.
  • Wagle is to file an additional affidavit explaining his post, rather than offer an oral clarification.
  • Both must be physically present on 8 December, when the matter will be taken up at 2 pm, as per LawBeat. The bench indicated it would pass a detailed order after going through the affidavits.

The arguments

SCBA president and senior advocate Pradeep Rai told the court that Raut was a "habitual offender" and that the matter "has to be dealt with an iron hand", the reports said. Rai argued that Raut had apologised but then put out further posts targeting the judiciary, which his affidavit did not disclose. Among the posts he cited, according to LiveLaw, were a claim that the BJP controls the country's democracy, judiciary, central agencies and the Election Commission, and a photograph of Albania's Supreme Court being set on fire by protesters. Rai also said separate contempt proceedings against Raut are pending in the Bombay High Court, LawBeat reported.

Raut's lawyer did not defend the remarks but asked the court to keep in mind that the MP is being treated for cancer and heart ailments, LiveLaw reported.

Senior advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle, said the post was a slip, that he had deleted it and apologised unconditionally. She opposed the demand for his personal appearance, sought his discharge and said the larger question of whether an abusive word aimed at a judge amounts to contempt by itself needs to be examined. "I want guidance from the Court so that I can advise my client what to do," LawBeat quoted her as saying.

How the case began

According to LiveLaw, the SCBA's petition says Wagle posted a profane message addressed to the Chief Justice after the CJI declined to meet a delegation of Opposition leaders. The association has also accused Raut of making false statements, including that judges attend ruling-party events and dinners hosted by chief ministers. Attorney General R Venkataramani gave his consent for the contempt petition, calling the comments prima facie "scandalous", the report said.

LawBeat's account of the earlier hearings says the court issued contempt notices to both men on 16 October. On 28 October, Wagle's unconditional apology was read out in court, and the bench asked Wagle to appear virtually and Raut physically. Raut tendered an unconditional apology on 29 October.

PS