The Supreme Court has set aside the removal of a Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) constable and ordered his immediate reinstatement, holding that an employee's past misconduct cannot be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct or used to make up for weak proof of new charges, legal news website LiveLaw reported on Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
According to the report, a bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh decided the case, Sumit Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., with Justice Sharma writing the judgment. The court directed that the constable be given all consequential benefits and 50% of back wages from the date of his removal until reinstatement, and declined to order a fresh inquiry.
How the case began
As reported by LiveLaw, Kumar sought leave in December 2017 to look after his wife, who had serious medical complications following a miscarriage and surgery. The request was initially declined. He then submitted a conditional resignation through the departmental grievance portal, citing acute mental stress, and was later granted 12 days' leave.
The CISF opened disciplinary proceedings against him. The charges alleged that he tried to pressure the administration through the resignation, circulated a video of his wife, and used relatives to threaten senior officers. The inquiry officer found all the charges proved and Kumar was removed from service in May 2018, the report said.
What the court found
The Supreme Court held that the charges were not adequately established and that removal was grossly disproportionate to the conduct alleged, according to LiveLaw. Its account of the findings:
- The video: A departmental witness said the video came from a different mobile number and was not sent by Kumar. Records showed he was at his CISF unit when it was recorded at the hospital, and there was no satisfactory evidence linking him to its circulation.
- The relatives: Contact from people claiming to be his relatives was not enough without evidence connecting their conduct to him.
- The resignation: The conditional resignation had to be read in light of his wife's medical condition and did not show grave or deliberate indiscipline warranting removal.
On past misconduct
The court said past misconduct cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct, according to LiveLaw's report of the judgment. An employee's earlier service record may be looked at while deciding the penalty for misconduct that has been independently established, the court held, but earlier minor penalties cannot cure deficient proof of the charges at hand.
Procedural lapses
The bench also found fault with the way the inquiry was run, the report said. Hindi translations of the documents relied on were given to Kumar only after the prosecution evidence had closed, and his request for a defence assistant was rejected despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001. The court held that these lapses denied him an effective opportunity to defend himself.
Senior Advocate Rakesh Kumar Khanna appeared for Kumar and Additional Solicitor General Brijender Chahar for the Union of India, according to LiveLaw. The report did not state the date on which the judgment was delivered or describe earlier proceedings in the case.




