An employee on probation can be let go as unsuitable after a complaint or an inquiry into suitability, and such an order does not become a punishment just because it gives no reasons, the Supreme Court held on Monday, 16 November. A bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu dismissed the appeal of Dr G Srinivasan, an associate professor whose probation was ended by a centrally funded earth sciences institute, LiveLaw reported.

The case

According to the LiveLaw report on the judgment in Dr G Srinivasan vs Union of India, Dr Srinivasan had been appointed on probation as an Associate Professor at the Centre for Earth Sciences, which is funded by the Union government. The order ending his service recorded that he was not suitable for confirmation because of his inability to fraternise with co-workers.

He challenged the order in the Karnataka High Court, where a single judge and then a division bench both ruled against him. Before the Supreme Court he argued that the order carried a stigma and had been passed without giving him a hearing. The institute replied that the order contained no adverse remark or imputation, that its scheme, regulations and bye-laws allow a simple termination without reasons, and that the complaint against him was only the motive for the order, not its foundation.

What the court held

The judgment, written by Justice Datta, said probation is a trial period meant to let an employer assess suitability and part ways with an unsuitable employee without a formal inquiry. A termination can be attacked as punitive only when the order goes beyond unsuitability, for instance by alleging misconduct, the court said as reported by LiveLaw.

"Mere use of a word like 'unsatisfactory' or 'unsuitable' does not amount to stigma," the bench said, according to LiveLaw.

The court found that the order against Dr Srinivasan did not attribute misconduct or moral turpitude to him and that the institute's decision followed an assessment of his suitability during probation. It added that "a grievance, a complaint, or an adverse perception, without more, remains chaff".

The test courts must apply

LiveLaw reported that the bench set out how courts should examine such cases:

  • Judges may look behind the wording of a termination order, but only to see whether "unsuitability" is a cover for punishing a specific act of misconduct. They are not to reassess suitability themselves.
  • The difference between motive and foundation is a matter of substance. The whole record has to be examined to see whether misconduct merely prompted the order or actually formed its basis.
  • On stigma, three questions are asked in order: whether the order on its face imputes anything against the probationer; if not, whether the material shows the foundation is misconduct rather than suitability; and if so, whether that carries civil consequences likely to affect future employment. Stigma arises only when the second and third answers are both yes.

The bench also said the test in the earlier Pavanendra Narayan Verma ruling is not exhaustive and has to be read with the stigma test and the object-of-inquiry test.

When an inquiry is still needed

If an order in truth punishes a particular act, due process must be followed, the court said. Where Article 311(2) of the Constitution applies, an inquiry under that provision is required; in other cases, an inquiry under the applicable service rules and the principles of natural justice is needed. A good-faith assessment of suitability, on the other hand, stands as a simple termination.

Senior Advocate Jayant Bhushan appeared for Dr Srinivasan, while Senior Advocates S S Ramdas and Shanthkumar Mahale appeared for the respondents, LiveLaw reported.

PS