This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. It responds to the decision of the Madhya Pradesh Cabinet, chaired by Chief Minister Dr Mohan Yadav at Gandhi Sagar in Mandsaur district on 18 November 2026, to scrap the two-child norm for government jobs and drop pending disciplinary cases against employees with a third child.

The decision is right in principle. But the way it has been made leaves two jobs unfinished: explaining it with evidence, and dealing fairly with the people the old rule has already punished.

What did the Madhya Pradesh Cabinet decide?

The Cabinet approved deleting the two-child provisions from the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (General Conditions of Service) Rules, 1961, and the Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1965, according to reports by the Free Press Journal and the news agency IANS. Since 26 January 2001, a third child born on or after that date made a person ineligible for a state government job and exposed serving staff to disciplinary action. Pending proceedings based only on a third child are to end; cases already closed with a final order will not be reopened, the reports said.

IANS quoted Dr Yadav as saying: "When other members of the society can have more than two children, why only government employees be restricted." The government cited a declining reproduction rate in the state but did not publish figures.

Why is ending the rule the right call?

Because it punished a private family decision with the loss of a livelihood, and the demographic case for it has weakened sharply. The Economic Survey's state-wise table of National Family Health Survey data shows Madhya Pradesh's total fertility rate falling from 3.9 children per woman in NFHS-1 (1992-93) to 3.1 in NFHS-3 (2005-06) and 2.0 in NFHS-5 (2019-21). The Union Health Ministry has described the national NFHS-5 figure of 2.0 as reaching the replacement level of 2.1 children per woman.

The Population Foundation of India, in a February 2026 statement reported by Down To Earth, argued that two-child rules turn children, especially daughters, into liabilities, and cited a study by former IAS officer Nirmala Buch that found more unsafe and sex-selective abortions in states with such rules and no sustained fall in fertility. A norm with those side-effects and doubtful benefits is hard to defend in a state whose own survey data show fertility near replacement level.

What is the strongest case against the decision?

The strongest objection is that fertility is not uniformly low. Writing in the Free Press Journal in July 2026, senior journalist Bhavdeep Kang argued that states such as Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh still have fertility above the national average and should be tightening, not loosening, population policy.

These concerns deserve an answer. But a bar on government jobs is a blunt and coercive tool. As the Population Foundation of India points out, states that lowered fertility did so through gender equality, girls' education, women's employment and voluntary family planning, not penalties.

What should the state do now?

First, publish the data. If a declining reproduction rate justified the change, the government should release the figures it relied on, alongside the formal notification of the amended rules, so citizens can judge the reasoning.

Second, do not stop at pending cases. IANS reported that 8,000 to 10,000 cases are pending across departments, while people already dismissed under final orders will not get relief. A rule judged unfair today was no fairer for someone removed years ago. A time-bound review, allowing those dismissed solely for a third child to apply for reinstatement or compensation, would complete the reform.

Third, invest the political energy in what works: better access to voluntary contraception and to schooling and jobs for women. Ending a punitive rule is a good start. Making the decision transparent and fair to those already harmed is what will make it a good policy.

Photo source · LRBurdak, CC BY-SA 3.0