This is a MapMyTimes opinion piece. On 22 November 2026, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), the national food regulator, said in a social media post that it had sanctioned prosecution of Bisleri International Pvt Ltd under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, after a sample of the company's packaged drinking water was declared unsafe. MapMyTimes reported the decision the same day. Our view: the regulator has done the right thing by acting, but it should now tell the public exactly what was found, in which batch, and whether any water on shop shelves is affected.

What did the regulator actually say?

FSSAI said very little beyond the bare finding. According to the regulator's statement as reported by PTI, a regulatory sample of "Packaged Drinking Water (other than Mineral Water)" taken from Bisleri's premises was found non-compliant with the prescribed bromate limit and declared unsafe. The company appealed, and a referral food laboratory also declared the sample unsafe, this time citing the detection of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). FSSAI then granted sanction to prosecute.

The same announcement listed prosecution sanctions against Vasant Masala Pvt Ltd, Tit-Bit Foods India Pvt Ltd, Mimansa Industries and Asha Confectionery, licence suspensions for Urmi Lifesciences LLP and Gaur Ayurvedic Store, and a recall of Asha Confectionery's chocolate-filled cookies. No recall of any Bisleri product was announced, and no response from Bisleri had been reported at the time of writing.

Why is a one-line announcement not enough?

A one-line announcement leaves the people who drink the product guessing. The public statement, as reported, does not say when or where the sample was collected, which batch or pack size it came from, or how far above the limit the measured levels were. It also leaves an obvious question hanging: the first laboratory flagged bromate and the referral laboratory flagged PAHs. Both findings led to the same "unsafe" label, but readers are entitled to know whether the two labs tested for the same things and how the results should be read together.

Packaged water is not a niche product. Households, travellers and offices across India buy it precisely because they want certainty about what they drink. FSSAI itself recognised the risk when, in an order dated 29 November 2024, it placed packaged drinking water and mineral water in its "high-risk" food category, bringing mandatory risk inspections and annual third-party audits for centrally licensed manufacturers. A regulator that treats a product as high-risk should also treat information about failures in that product as something consumers need.

What is the strongest case for saying less?

There is a fair argument for restraint, and it deserves to be taken seriously. A sanction to prosecute is the start of a legal process, not a verdict, and any finding of guilt is for a court. Publishing detailed figures before a trial could prejudice the case, and a single failed sample from one batch does not by itself show that a company's entire output is unsafe. Excessive publicity could cause needless panic, hurt a business that may yet be cleared, and even discourage firms from using the appeal route the law gives them.

Those concerns are real, but they argue for careful disclosure, not for silence. Stating the batch, the date and place of sampling, the parameter tested, the measured value against the legal limit, and whether a recall has been considered is factual information. It does not pre-judge guilt. It simply lets buyers check whether anything in their cupboard is affected, and it lets the company respond to specifics rather than to rumour.

What should change?

We would suggest three practical steps. First, every FSSAI enforcement post involving a product sold to the public should carry the batch or lot number, sampling date and the parameter that failed, with the measured value where it is not sub judice. Second, when a sample is declared unsafe, the regulator should say clearly whether a recall has been ordered and, if not, why not. Third, the company named should be invited to publish its own account, so that consumers hear both sides early.

The same principle runs through our earlier argument that private groundwater in Bhopal needs routine testing: water safety depends on test results that people can actually see. FSSAI's decision to act on a well-known brand shows that enforcement is not reserved for small operators. Pairing that resolve with clear, specific public information would make the action far more useful to the people it is meant to protect.

Photo source