The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has issued a conditional summons to Punjab's Chief Secretary over what it called serious safety violations in buses run under the state's Mukhyamantri Tirth Yatra Yojana. The action came a day after two buses operating under the pilgrimage scheme collided in Tarn Taran district on Saturday, 14 November.
According to IANS, the summons was issued by a bench presided over by NHRC Member Priyank Kanoongo. All India Radio reported that the Chief Secretary has been directed to appear before the Commission, in person or through a duly authorised representative, on 7 December, along with Action Taken Reports and other details sought.
Warnings that went unanswered
The summons follows a complaint the Commission had already taken up. In late October, The Hans India reported that the NHRC had taken cognisance of allegations that air-conditioned sleeper buses used under the scheme were unsafe. The complaint, filed by the Network for Access to Justice & Multidisciplinary Outreach Foundation, flagged alleged unauthorised structural modifications, partitions separating drivers' cabins from passengers, blocked emergency exits and weak fire safety and evacuation arrangements.
At that stage, the Commission issued notices to the Punjab Chief Secretary and the Secretary of the Union Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. It asked the state to inspect every bus deployed under the scheme, pull out any vehicle that failed mandatory safety standards, and file Action Taken Reports within seven days, the newspaper reported.
In its latest statement, quoted by IANS, the NHRC said the Chief Secretary "has not submitted the requisite Action Taken Report" despite specific and time-bound directions. "No report indicating the inspections conducted, safety deficiencies identified, corrective measures undertaken or accountability fixed has been received from the State Government till date," the Commission said.
'Cannot be implemented at the cost of human life'
The Commission deplored what it described as the "lackadaisical approach of the authorities". It said passenger safety on a government-sponsored welfare scheme, particularly for senior citizens and other vulnerable people, is the direct responsibility of the state and its regulators.
"Such schemes cannot be implemented at the cost of human life, and compliance with mandatory vehicle safety standards cannot be reduced to a mere procedural formality," the NHRC statement said, according to IANS.
The Tribune reported that the Commission has been pursuing passenger bus safety concerns across states for over a year, and in earlier proceedings had flagged recurring fatal accidents involving passenger and sleeper buses, structural deficiencies and violations of guidelines of the Central Institute of Road Transport (CIRT).
The Tarn Taran collision
The NHRC's statement referred to "four reported deaths and injuries to around 30 people" in the Tarn Taran crash. Later reports put the toll higher: All India Radio said five people died and around 30 were injured, while IANS reported five dead and 16 injured after the two pilgrim buses collided head-on on the Tarn Taran–Bathinda national highway near Naushehra Pannuan village.
Tarn Taran Senior Superintendent of Police Surendra Lamba said one bus driver swerved suddenly to avoid a motorcyclist coming from the wrong direction, and the bus then collided with another coming from the opposite side, ETV Bharat reported.
What the Commission wants
- Details of inspections of all buses under the scheme and their safety compliance
- Corrective measures taken and action against non-compliant vehicles
- A detailed report on the Tarn Taran accident
The summons is conditional: according to the NHRC, the Chief Secretary will have to appear in person only if comprehensive reports are not submitted by the deadline the Commission has set.
PS · Shimla Deities, CC BY-SA 4.0




