The Madhya Pradesh government has defended the extra marks given to in-service doctors in NEET PG counselling, telling the High Court at Jabalpur that "merit" for postgraduate medical admission now includes professional experience. Legal news portal LiveLaw reported the hearing on 17 November 2026 and said the matter is listed again on 18 November at 2:30 pm.

The case, titled Sarvjeet Singh v. State of MP, is before a Division Bench of Chief Justice Alpesh Y. Kogje and Justice Vivek Jain. According to LiveLaw, the Bench recorded the submissions of both sides and adjourned the matter. The report does not mention any fresh order or any observation by the Bench at this hearing.

What the fresh candidates say

The petition has been filed by a fresh candidate, meaning one who is not a serving government doctor. Senior Advocate Aditya Sanghi, appearing with Advocates Vinita Ahuja and Alka Singh, relied on Rule 14 of the MP Chikitsa Shiksha Pravesh Niyam, 2018, under which in-service candidates get incentive weightage linked to their length of service.

As reported by LiveLaw, he argued that these marks push in-service doctors up the merit list, ahead of fresh candidates who scored higher in NEET PG. He submitted that in-service doctors form a separate channel of admission and cannot use the enhanced score to compete for open-category seats. Citing the Supreme Court's 2012 decision in Satyabrata Sahoo v. State of Orissa, he said such candidates cannot take both the separate 30% quota and incentive marks to improve their open-category position.

LiveLaw quoted him as telling the court that "the top six out of the top 10 are all in-service candidates" in the open category.

What the State told the court

The Additional Solicitor General, appearing for the State, argued that amendments to the postgraduate medical education regulations removed the words "academic merit", and that Regulation 9 now speaks only of "merit", which therefore covers professional experience too, LiveLaw reported.

The State said incentive marks are meant to give a level playing field to doctors who serve in rural and tribal areas. It also contended that the petitioner is questioning only how candidates are considered during counselling and has not challenged the incentive-marks provision itself. According to the report, the State added that the advantage from incentive marks does not depend on the 30% quota, and that in-service candidates would rank higher for open-category seats even without it.

Interim direction already in place

In an earlier order reported by LiveLaw on 3 November 2026, the same Bench had directed that allotment of branches to in-service candidates be limited to the 30% seats shown for them in the State's seat distribution for MD/MS courses. In that order the Bench noted the petitioners' case that in-service candidates were getting a "dual benefit" and that this was "causing great injustice to the fresh students who are having higher NEET PG score".

That report gave one example cited before the court: an in-service candidate with an all-India rank of 13865 was placed at merit position 333 after incentive marks were added.

What happens next

The matter is listed for further hearing on 18 November 2026 at 2:30 pm, according to LiveLaw. Until the court decides otherwise, the earlier interim direction limiting in-service allotments to the 30% seats continues to be the reported position.

PS · Gyanendra_Singh_Chau…, CC BY 3.0