Filmmaker Imtiaz Ali said on Saturday that the Hindi film industry is going through "a phase of introspection", pointing to the success of the Dhurandhar films as proof that the rules many in Bollywood rely on are being overturned. He was speaking at the 24th Hindustan Times Leadership Summit (HTLS) in conversation with Sonal Kalra, Chief Managing Editor, Entertainment and Lifestyle, at Hindustan Times, according to the newspaper's reports of the session. Actor Ananya Panday shared the stage with him.

Ali also defended his latest release, the Partition-era drama Main Vaapas Aaunga, saying he never regarded it as a risky project.

"Nothing is working" – and yet long films are

Describing the current mood in the industry, Ali said, as quoted by Hindustan Times: "We are in that delicious phase where people are saying that nothing is working." He noted that producers are unsure whether to back a big star or a non-star, and that the industry worries about audiences' shrinking attention spans, even though, in his words, "the films which are doing well are three hours long."

He singled out Aditya Dhar's spy thriller as the clearest example. According to Hindustan Times, Ali recalled that when Dhurandhar was doing the rounds of studios, people saw it as "the most impractical, a film with the least likelihood of success". He added: "But it broke all the rules and after that everybody wants to make that."

"The language might change but I feel its a phase of introspection that the film industry is going through." – Imtiaz Ali, as reported by Hindustan Times

What Dhurandhar earned

Hindustan Times, in its report on the session, put the combined worldwide gross of the two Dhurandhar films above ₹3,000 crore. The first film, starring Ranveer Singh, released in December and finished its theatrical run, which lasted more than 14 weeks, at ₹1,308 crore worldwide, the paper said. Its sequel, Dhurandhar: The Revenge, released in March and, by the paper's count, had earned just over ₹1,025 crore net in India and ₹1,720 crore worldwide as of 16 April; the makers have claimed a worldwide figure above ₹1,760 crore. Hindustan Times described the two films as the highest-grossing Hindi films in India.

"There was no Pakistan in my film"

On Main Vaapas Aaunga, Ali rejected the idea that setting a story during Partition was a gamble. "I knew that there was no Pakistan in my film; it was undivided India," he said, as quoted by Hindustan Times, explaining that the places shown lay across a border that was drawn only later.

He said the film grew out of conversations with people who had lived through Partition. In his view, the perspective of survivors now in their seventies is missing from the media, and their memories differ from those of first-generation refugees. Ali said these elders tend to remember the beautiful and happy moments more than the anger or loss, calling this "the victory of human emotion", and said he felt he had to tell the story while some of them are still alive.

"I never thought it's a risky film," he said, adding that he did not expect anything in it to be controversial or hurtful to anyone.

Betting on Gen Z

Ali said he was certain young audiences would connect with the film. According to Hindustan Times, he said Gen Z "more than anyone will relate to a painful love story", because many of them miss the kind of commitment they see in films or read about in books.

Main Vaapas Aaunga released in June with Naseeruddin Shah, Diljit Dosanjh, Sharvari and Vedang Raina in the lead roles, and Hindustan Times described it as a surprise box-office hit. It is now streaming on Netflix.

Why it matters

Ali's comments come from a director whose own recent film defied expectations, and they echo a wider uncertainty in Hindi cinema about what audiences will pay to see. His argument is that recent hits – long, unconventional and initially doubted – show that the industry's familiar formulas are no longer reliable guides.

PS