Former Madras and Calcutta High Court judge C.S. Karnan, the first sitting high court judge in India to be sent to prison for contempt of court, died in Chennai on Friday, 13 November. He was 71.

Karnan had recently been admitted to a private hospital in Chennai with health complications and died after he stopped responding to treatment, according to reports by LiveLaw and The Wire. No cause of death has been made public. LiveLaw reported that his funeral was to be held on Saturday, 14 November.

From Cuddalore to the high court

Born Karunanithi in 1955 in Karnatham village in Tamil Nadu's Cuddalore district, Karnan graduated from Madras Law College in 1983 and practised as an advocate. He was appointed an additional judge of the Madras High Court in March 2009 and became a permanent judge in 2011.

His years on the bench were marked by repeated clashes with fellow judges. Karnan, who is from a Dalit community, alleged that he faced caste-based discrimination and harassment within the judiciary, and named the then Chief Justice of the Madras High Court, Sanjay Kishan Kaul. In 2014 he walked into another bench's hearing on judicial appointments to object to the selection process, an episode the Supreme Court criticised.

Transfer and a clash with the Supreme Court

In 2016 the Supreme Court transferred him to the Calcutta High Court. Karnan challenged the move and at one point issued his own order to stay it, triggering a major controversy.

In January 2017 he wrote to the Prime Minister accusing a number of sitting and retired judges of corruption. The Supreme Court began contempt proceedings on its own. Karnan responded by passing orders against Supreme Court judges, including one that purported to sentence the then Chief Justice of India and other judges to five years in prison.

On 9 May 2017, a seven-judge bench headed by Chief Justice J.S. Khehar held him guilty of contempt and sentenced him to six months in prison, ordering his immediate arrest. Karnan could not be traced for more than a month and retired on 12 June 2017 while still evading the police. He was later arrested in Coimbatore, served his sentence in Kolkata's Presidency Jail and was released in December 2017.

Later years

After leaving the bench, Karnan entered politics. In 2020 he was again in trouble with the law after videos surfaced in which he made derogatory remarks about judges and women judicial officers. A case was registered, and the Madras High Court later granted him bail, citing his unconditional apology and his medical condition, LiveLaw reported.

Why his case matters

Karnan's case remains one of the most unusual episodes in the history of India's higher judiciary. He was the first sitting high court judge to be jailed for contempt, and his open conflict with the Supreme Court played out while he was still in office. His supporters, Siasat reported, saw his stand as a fight for fair treatment and equal representation in the judiciary, while the Supreme Court found that his actions amounted to contempt.

What happens next

Reports did not say whether any formal condolence reference would be held in the Madras or Calcutta High Courts. Details of his surviving family have not been made public in the reports.

PS · Shyamal, CC BY-SA 4.0