The Delhi High Court has ordered a man and his wife to vacate the south Delhi house of his 85-year-old father within four weeks, ruling that a senior citizen cannot be compelled to share his own house with his children against his wishes. Justice Amit Mahajan allowed the father's petition in a judgment dated 20 November 2026, which was reported on 22 November.

Does a parent have to prove ill-treatment to evict a child?

No, the court said. Relying on an earlier Delhi High Court ruling in Pritam Singh v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Justice Mahajan held that a senior citizen seeking to evict his children under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 "is not necessarily required to show that he has been ill-treated by them". "It is sufficient if he shows that his property needs protection, so that he can live therein peacefully and with dignity," the judgment says.

The court also cited the Supreme Court's August 2026 ruling in Ravi Kant Gupta v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which held that tribunals under the Act can order the eviction of children from a senior citizen's property where that is needed for his maintenance and protection.

What was the case?

The petitioner, Subhash Chander Malhotra, owns the house, which the judgment records he acquired from the Delhi Development Authority in 1980. His eldest son and daughter-in-law have lived there since their marriage in 2003. He alleged that their behaviour worsened over the years, that they stopped supporting him, and that harassment intensified after his wife died in November 2020. He has filed several police complaints since 2022.

The son and daughter-in-law argued that the allegations were driven by a business dispute between the brothers, that they had cared for the father, and that they had offered him Rs 15,000 a month in maintenance.

The District Magistrate (South) rejected the father's plea in October 2025, calling it a family and property dispute, and the Divisional Commissioner upheld that order on 28 April 2026.

Why did the High Court overturn the orders?

Justice Mahajan said both authorities had demanded "clear and cogent evidence" of harassment, a condition that neither the Act nor the Delhi rules of 2009 impose, and so had committed an error of law. They had also ignored the police complaints and two earlier High Court orders directing police to help the father.

The court found that the reports of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, on which both orders relied, did not analyse the material on record. "A conclusion bereft of reasons cannot be termed a finding," the judgment says. A business dispute between the sons, it added, could not by itself make the father's grievance false.

The court noted that harassment of elderly parents often happens "within the four walls of the house" and is hard to prove, and that proceedings under the Act are summary in nature. "At the age of 85 years, the petitioner is entitled to live in his own house peacefully and with dignity," it said.

What happens next?

The orders of the District Magistrate and Divisional Commissioner were set aside. The son and daughter-in-law must leave the house within four weeks of 20 November, and the local police station's SHO has been told to help the father enforce the order if needed.

Photo source