The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday upheld the death sentence awarded to Ashok Singh, who was convicted of raping and murdering his neighbour's five-year-old daughter in November 2024, legal news portal Bar and Bench reported. A Division Bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray held that the case qualifies as one of the "rarest of the rare", the report said.

The Bench also put the execution of the sentence on hold for three months so that Singh can approach the Supreme Court, and ordered the West Bengal government to pay ₹15 lakh to the child's parents within two months, according to the report. The case is titled State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh.

What the case was about

As recounted in the Bar and Bench report, the girl went to a neighbour's house on 24 November 2024 and did not come back. People searching for her found her unconscious, unclothed and bleeding at Singh's home. She was taken to a hospital, where she was declared dead.

The trial court convicted Singh of raping a child below twelve years of age, aggravated sexual assault and murder, and sentenced him to death, treating the case as "rarest of rare". The matter then came before the High Court.

Arguments on both sides

Singh's lawyers argued that the prosecution rested wholly on circumstantial evidence, that the "last seen" theory was not conclusive proof of guilt, and that nothing showed he was the only person present in his house, the report said.

The State countered that the witnesses supported one another, that Singh could not properly explain how the child came to be found at his home, and that the DNA findings backed the prosecution's case.

Why the Bench confirmed the sentence

According to the report, the court relied on a witness who saw Singh approach the girl and lure her with chocolates, and on a forensic report that found his DNA on the victim's body. The judges concluded that he had tracked the child's movements so as to avoid eyewitnesses.

The Bench weighed a lesser punishment before settling on death, the report said. It noted that doctors and forensic experts who deposed found Singh lucid and free of any mental or emotional illness, and that he showed no remorse. The court also recorded that he was under suspicion of having inappropriately touched another five-year-old girl. It described the child's death as involving "extreme depravity" and found Singh to be "beyond reformation", Bar and Bench reported.

State pulled up over compensation

The judges criticised the State for not having paid compensation to the victim's parents and directed that ₹15 lakh be paid to them within two months, the report said.

What happens next

  • The death sentence will not be carried out for three months, a window in which Singh can appeal to the Supreme Court.
  • The High Court will take up the matter again on 30 January 2027 to check whether its compensation order has been followed.

Singh was represented by advocates Amit Ranjan Pati, Swastika Chowdhury, Ilika Nag, Yavik Singhal and Avijit Chatterjee. Special Public Prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee led the State's team. Senior Advocate Kaushik Gupta and advocate Apalak Basu appeared on appointment by the Calcutta High Court Legal Services Committee, according to the report.

PS · রবিরশ্মি রায়, CC BY-SA 4.0