The Calcutta High Court has ordered the Mizoram government to complete the sale of a state-owned plot in central Kolkata to the private company that won it at auction. The court rejected the state's attempt to cancel the deal after a change of government and called the cancellation a case of "regime revenge", according to a Bar and Bench report published on 14 November.
A division bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray dismissed the State of Mizoram's appeal against Excel Vincom Private Limited, the buyer. The report says the ruling was delivered on Friday, 13 November. The bench gave the state eight weeks to execute the sale.
The property and the auction
The plot, at 24 Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue in Kolkata, was bought by Mizoram in 1973. The state has used it as a guesthouse and for offices, known as Mizoram House.
In May 2023, the Mizoram government put the property up through an e-tender-cum-e-auction. Excel Vincom was the highest bidder at about ₹38.3 crore, and an agreement for sale was signed on 6 October 2023. The final sale deed, however, was never executed.
Why the new government cancelled
A new government took office in Mizoram in December 2023 and cancelled the tender, saying it was against public interest. The decision followed representations from Kolkata Mizo Students and the Calcutta Mizo Welfare Association. They pointed to the building's heritage value and said it served as a place of refuge for Mizo students and professionals living in Kolkata.
Before the bench, Advocate General Biswajit Deb argued that community sentiment, not the change of government, drove the cancellation. He said the state had refunded the full payment and that, since ownership passes only when a sale deed is signed, the state was free to cancel at any time.
Senior Advocate S.N. Mookherjee, for Excel Vincom, argued that cancellation was no longer an option once everything except the sale deed had been completed, and that the sale stopped abruptly because the government changed.
What the court held
The bench noted that the state had received the full sale price and had even accepted penalty interest for a delayed instalment. It found no justification for cancelling the deal and held the cancellation to be unjust, arbitrary and in breach of Article 14 of the Constitution, which guarantees equality before the law.
"It does appear to us that this is a case of 'regime revenge'," the bench observed, according to the report. It said a state, when it enters a contract, must behave fairly, justly and reasonably, and that Mizoram had not shown any public interest, let alone an overwhelming one, to justify going back on the tender.
"The Government cannot renege on a promise made and acted upon by a citizen to his detriment..."
Why it matters
The ruling deals with a recurring question: whether a new government can undo commercial commitments made by its predecessor. The bench's view is that a completed public auction cannot be set aside merely because those in power have changed, unless a strong public interest is shown.
What happens next
A single judge had in 2024 directed the state to complete the sale within six weeks; the division bench has now upheld the outcome and allowed eight weeks. Mizoram has the option of seeking further legal remedies, but the report did not say whether the state plans to approach the Supreme Court.




