Anganwadi centres count as educational institutions under West Bengal's excise rules, so a liquor shop cannot be set up within 1,000 feet of one, the Calcutta High Court has held, dismissing an appeal by a shop owner in Hooghly district who wanted to move his outlet closer to such a centre.
A Division Bench of Justice Shampa Sarkar and Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee passed the order on 12 November 2026 in Aloke Kuma Dey vs The State of West Bengal & Ors. (MAT 2297 of 2025), upholding a single-judge ruling of 5 October 2023. The order was reported by the legal news portal LiveLaw on 14 November.
The dispute
According to the order, the appellant ran a foreign liquor shop, "Tinar More CS Shop", from rented premises at Mouza Tinar under Sarai Tinar Gram Panchayat in Hooghly. When he applied to shift the business to his own land, the excise authority refused because the new site fell within 1,000 feet of an anganwadi centre.
He challenged the refusal in a writ petition, arguing that an anganwadi is not a "recognised educational institution" under Rule 8(1) of the West Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules, 2003, which bars liquor outlets near such institutions. A single judge disagreed and dismissed the petition.
In appeal, his lawyer argued that anganwadi centres are not governed by any statutory framework of the school education department, and that the proposed shop was in any case more than 1,000 feet away. The State, represented by an Additional Government Pleader, relied on a 20 January 2012 excise department notification which, it said, clarified that anganwadi centres could not be left out of the meaning of "educational institution" under Rule 8.
What the court held
The Bench said it found no "infirmity" or "perversity" in the single judge's findings. It noted that:
- Anganwadi centres are set up under the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) scheme and provide care and elementary education to children aged three to six.
- The National Food Security Act, 2013 defines an anganwadi as a child care and development centre set up under ICDS.
- Section 11 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 asks governments to arrange pre-school education, and West Bengal's 2012 RTE Rules require local authorities to record, for each child up to six, the name of the school, pre-school or anganwadi centre the child attends.
"The fact that they are educational institutions, recognized by law is not in doubt," the Bench wrote, adding that anganwadis therefore fall within the category of a school for the purposes of Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules.
Why it matters
The ruling confirms that the 1,000-feet buffer West Bengal's excise rules set around educational institutions also applies to anganwadi centres, which the court noted provide care and early education to children aged three to six.
What next for the appellant
The appeal was dismissed without costs. However, the court said the order would not stop the shop owner from approaching the authority again if he believes the proposed site is in fact beyond 1,000 feet of the centre; the authority must then act in accordance with law after giving him notice.
The Bench also condoned the delay in filing the appeal, which the appellant attributed to serious illness in his family, but made it subject to costs of Rs 5,000, payable within three weeks to the West Bengal State Legal Services Authority for the High Court's Juvenile Justice Committee fund.
PS · Indrajit Das, CC BY-SA 4.0




