The Ministry of External Affairs on Friday, 13 November, said decisions on visas are a "sovereign function" of any government. It was responding to Congress MP Shashi Tharoor's allegation that 115 foreign speakers invited to the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad had been refused entry to India or had their visas cancelled.
What the government said
Asked about the row at his regular media briefing, MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said, "Visa matters are sovereign functions of any country or any government. So that is what I have to say," according to a PTI report carried by ThePrint. He did not say which ministry, if any, ordered visas to be withdrawn.
Tharoor's allegation
Tharoor said on Friday that 115 of 315 scheduled speakers had been refused entry or had their visas cancelled "apparently on the instructions of the Ministry of Home Affairs", even though they had MEA clearance to attend, Scroll reported. "It is completely unclear under what provision of law the government has taken such a drastic step," he wrote, adding that it was a shame "a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical".
The 115 figure is Tharoor's claim and has not been confirmed by the government. Scroll noted that party functionaries put the number of foreign delegates given political clearance by the foreign ministry at 316, slightly different from the 315 in Tharoor's post, and that organisers said about 200 international delegates were attending.
The Norwegian journalist's case
The most widely reported case is that of Helle Lyng Svendsen, a journalist with the Norwegian newspaper Dagsavisen. She said the Indian embassy in Oslo told her not to travel about 10 minutes before she was due to leave for the airport, even though she held a visa and political clearance and was to speak on media and press freedom, Scroll reported. In a post on X, she said "'orders from above' in the Ministry of Home Affairs have cancelled my visa" and appealed to Home Minister Amit Shah to allow her visit, according to PTI.
Svendsen had drawn attention in May when, at a joint press appearance in Oslo on 18 May, she asked Prime Minister Narendra Modi why he does not take questions from the press, Scroll reported. The Congress party posted on X on Thursday asking "Why are Modi and his government so afraid of questions", PTI said. The Home Ministry and the embassy had not commented on her allegations when Scroll published its report.
BJP response
Telangana BJP president N Ramchander Rao on Saturday called the event an "anti-Bharat Summit" and defended the cancellations, the Deccan Chronicle reported. Speaking to ANI, he said cancelling a visa is the "prerogative of any government" and alleged that people who had written against the Modi government were invited with the "sole intention of creating anarchy". The BRS asked the state government to explain what the summit offered Telangana, the paper said.
About the summit
The two-day Bharat Summit is being held in Hyderabad on 13 and 14 November. Reports describe it as organised by the Congress and the Congress-led Telangana government, with sessions on democracy, social and economic justice, climate change, gender equality and foreign policy.
What remains unclear
The government has not said how many visas were refused or withdrawn, which authority made the decisions, or under what legal provision. With the summit ending on Saturday, it is unlikely that affected speakers can still attend.




