Grandparents having more money than a child's mother is not, by itself, a reason to take the child away from her, the Allahabad High Court has ruled, upholding an order that handed an eight-year-old boy back to his widowed mother.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra dismissed a special appeal filed by the boy's paternal grandparents, according to a LiveLaw report published on Sunday, 15 November. The case is titled Manoj Sahlot and another vs State of UP and 6 others.
How the dispute began
According to the mother's account before the court, she learnt on 28 November 2025 that her husband had died by suicide in Ghaziabad. She went there the next day with her parents and both her children. After the cremation, she alleged, her in-laws kept her son with them.
She said she approached the police but got no relief, and then filed a habeas corpus petition seeking custody of the boy. The couple's younger child, a daughter of about four, has always lived with her.
On 27 May 2026, a Single Judge examined affidavits from both sides on their incomes, assets and plans for the child, and directed that the boy be handed over to his mother.
What the grandparents argued
In their appeal, the grandparents said the boy's welfare lay with them because the mother did not earn enough to bring him up. They told the court she makes about Rs 20,000 a month by tutoring ten students, and argued that the Single Judge had given her custody only because she is the mother. They also challenged the refusal to grant them visiting rights.
What the High Court held
The Bench found that the Single Judge had weighed the full record. This included criminal cases filed by both sides, the father's death, the grandparents keeping the child, Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, and the boy's schooling. The earlier order had also considered his young age, the mother's continuous care, emotional bonds and her role in his upbringing.
The judges noted that the daughter had always been with her mother, and only the son had been kept by the grandparents after his father's cremation.
The court said the fact that the grandparents "may be having better financial resources" than the mother "cannot be a ground for depriving the mother of custody of her minor son". It observed that they were free to support the child's upbringing financially instead.
Calling the Single Judge's decision a "well structured order", the Bench declined to interfere.
What happens next
The grandparents told the court that proceedings under the Guardians and Wards Act were pending before a district court, but placed no records of them before the Bench. On visitation, the High Court said they could pursue their remedies before the district court or start fresh proceedings concerning the boy. For now, the eight-year-old stays with his mother and sister.




